Reviews of A Walk In The Woods

Marigold · 15 October 2005 · Chapter 1: Walking Party

I was just poking around the comments at the MEFA site and I agree with Rabidsamfan - this story needs a sequel! I have enjoyed reading this again, several times over the past couple of months! It remains one of my favourite stories : )

Author's reply

You think? Oh, I have never thought that. To be honest, this is the least favourite of all the stories I have written, but I promise that I shall think about it. :D I am happy that others like it though, because that means that what I think about my stories isn¨t necessarily what others think. ;)

Periantari · 2 February 2005 · Chapter 3: The Proud and The Brave

this is such a lovely story~ i love how Pippin didn't just panic and used his wits and was calm enough to remember all that Merry has taught him to help him into the cave. Pippin was so brave....very wise 14 year old. =) and i love the h/c that you describe. Written very well indeed :) i was aww-ing at the end when Merry hugged Pippin and such and :*) yeah..very nice :)

Author's reply

Thank you! I`m glad you liked it.

Auntiemeesh · 3 August 2004 · Chapter 3: The Proud and The Brave

I liked this a lot, from Pippin's excited eagerness to go to Hobbiton, to his bravery when Merry was hurt and needed help, to his resourcefulness in giving that help. Good job!

Author's reply

Pip is more resourceful than we sometimes think. Merry has taught him well. Thank you for reading!

powerwriter · 1 March 2004 · Chapter 3: The Proud and The Brave

You need a review for this! Very good, simple story. It got a little wordy in chapter two, but I can understand since it was a lot of detailed action. Moving on to read your other story...

Reviews (4)