For Gondor by Wyndhamfan
Stefania · 16 March 2012 · Chapter 1: Blood Red
This is a nice beginning, Wyndhamfan. It's quite well-written. If I guess your intention correctly, you are doing the scenes that led up to the TTT EE film scene that showed Faramir and Boromir celebrating a bittersweet victory over Gondor's enemies. I haven't been on Stories of Arda much the past few years, so I am grateful to read a new story of Denethor's family. Keep it up, wherever you plan to take it.
Larner · 14 February 2012 · Chapter 1: Blood Red
Terrible portents of worse to come. And the Enemy has his folk well trained in sadism, it appears.
Claire · 7 April 2005 · Chapter 6: Fall into darkness
Please, continue this fic. It's really good.
Raksha The Demon · 12 December 2004 · Chapter 6: Fall into darkness
How wonderful to see this story updated at last! Poor Faramir. Nicely written interaction between the brothers. Hopefully Boromir will get him home before he loses more blood...Wonder what Denethor will have to say.
katieelessar · 3 December 2004 · Chapter 5: Fighting the tide
AHHHHHHH!!! You must update! You put us on a freaken cliff hanger! Grrrr, please update soon!!! Please, please *on knees with Puss In Boots eyes* Please?
Author's reply
Hi! Er, updated. :P Sorry guys. My life has been chaotic the past few months. Working in the publishing industry can do that to you. ;)
Katieelessar · 27 November 2004 · Chapter 5: Fighting the tide
Wow. That's all I have to say. What a wonderful story you have here. I love how you interepted the family dynamics and the way Denethor would respond to Faramir's 'prophecy dreams.' And the fact that Faramir dreamed about his mother's death has a nice touch. I also liked the way you made the orcs attack the crops of Minas Tirith. It would be very devasting, I think. Faramir is much more opened minded than his brother, that's how I interpeted it. Over all a very good story. What will happen to Faramir!?? You left us on a cliff hanger! Grrr, I hate those. Keep writing! Please!!!!
Raksha · 1 June 2004 · Chapter 5: Fighting the tide
Oh my, things look bad for Faramir! Enjoying this and I'm so glad you updated! Please update again soon!
daw the minstrel · 15 April 2004 · Chapter 3: Separation
Faramir is certainly in a difficult position here, and he makes the harder choice of striking off on his own. He could follow orders, after all, and that would be honorable too. I think that foresight must be a very troubling gift.
Antigone Q · 13 March 2004 · Chapter 2: Conflict between brothers
I liked the interactions between Denethor, Boromir, and Faramir. Faramir's dreams in the LotR fascinated me; I'm interested to see what you'll do with them in this story.
LOTRFaith · 13 March 2004 · Chapter 2: Conflict between brothers
Hello! I read chapter 1 on ff.net and then despaired because I couldn't find it afterwards;-) Thank goodness you post here too;-) :-D I really like the chapters so far and hope to see more soon! Excellent job;-) Namaarie~ LOTRFaith