Reviews (7)

Pearl Took · 27 July 2004 · Chapter 1

This is truly touching. This is the perfect way to give "movie Pippin" his troll!! Wonderful!!

Hai Took · 12 June 2004 · Chapter 1

That was beautiful! My sister and I were talking about this the other day, the little conversation between Gandalf and Pippin we find to be one of the most touching and you captured it wonderfully! Pippin getting to fight the troll was great, I felt that Pippin, maybe even more for Merry, had been a bit cheated in ROTK. You did a gread job of blending book with movie! Thank you!

pipspebble · 11 June 2004 · Chapter 1

Oh, bravo! Finally, a "rest of scene" we were denied in the movie. Leave it to you to finish this in grand style. Thanks so much for showing the kind of stuff this halfling is made of. This was a peach of a story and I love it! Pips

white_rider · 11 June 2004 · Chapter 1

Hi There Yes!!.... I too was extremely dissappointed that Pippin didn't get to kill his troll in the movie as well....It was what I was most looking forward too...To see my brave Pip get his well deserved reward...Afterall Frodo and Sam had their Mount Doom ending....Merry had his Witchking moment....Even Aragorn got his Arwen (and a troll(no fair!!))....But then NO TROLL!! for Pip...What a travesty!!...I have been waiting for ages to see if someone would come up with a really good interpretation story of what may have happened between that scene (my favourite in the whole movie) with Gandalf and Pippin and the one with the Army of the Dead swarming the walls of Minas Tirith..... and this is it!!!...This is fantastic...I really love it.. Thank you so much....Now if only Peter Jackson could have come up with something like this... I would have been in even more thrall of the movie than I already am!!

Dreamflower · 11 June 2004 · Chapter 1

So very glad Pippin got his troll! I too, was disappointed in the movie not letting him kill a troll, although *maybe* in the EE? But I like your solution just fine. Beautifully done!

pipinheart · 11 June 2004 · Chapter 1

Really nice piece of work... I like that pippin and Gandalph together fighting side by side. And tthat in his fear pipin fight bravely and defeats a troll.... Good work...

Bodldops · 11 June 2004 · Chapter 1

Very nice movie-verse fix to a problem that irked me. Pip should have his troll, after all. I loved the way you wrote Gandalf and Pip, good job!