Reviews (4)

Pearl Took · 27 December 2004 · Chapter 1: A Very Dwarven Yule

This is magical!! A wonderful Yule gift. Thank you :-)

esamen · 26 December 2004 · Chapter 1: A Very Dwarven Yule

Bilbo took the wrapped gift and opened it, a smile on his face. It was a portable writing desk, like a smooth box that opened to reveal fresh paper and several bottles of ink, not to mention some finely crafted pens. Frodo leaned over Bilbo, looking on in astonishment. Oh, what a lovely story. You have written it so beautifully! All the characters are so live and real. As I read the lines above, I felt as if I could just see, smell and touch the whole scene. It's so much fun to visit Bag End. Thanks for a wonderful Christmas story.

Soledad · 26 December 2004 · Chapter 1: A Very Dwarven Yule

Awww, that was lovely! Thank you for bringing back some of the "Hobbit" Dwarves! I always loved them. And Pippin as a small child is just adorable.

Grey Wonderer · 26 December 2004 · Chapter 1: A Very Dwarven Yule

This is very cute! I love how you tie the white tree to Pippin's toys and then later to his real sword and shield. A lovely Yule story!