Coronation Details by Meldewen Ilce

Reviews (2)

Write a review

Dayna · 3 January 2005 · Chapter 1: Chapter I

Meldewen, PJ should have had you on staff. I LOVE THIS! I think this makes more sense than the scene PJ filmed! :O I love what you did with it. Great job! :)

Author's reply

Meldewen, PJ should have had you on staff. I LOVE THIS! I think this makes more sense than the scene PJ filmed! :O I love what you did with it. Great job! :) *blushes* Why thank you but I think I would have freaked if I had gotten a phone call one day from PJ asking me to join the writers... still I am flattered by your words! Though I admit I love a lot about the scene PJ filmed, though in some respects I wish it could have been more like the book, though I admit I do love the part where everyone bows down to the hobbits a great deal (so much so that this scene never fails to move me to tears)... Again thanks for your kind comments!

Raksha The Demon · 2 January 2005 · Chapter 1: Chapter I

Thank you for restoring Faramir to the coronation scene, as the Steward! I still don't care for Gimli's bearing the crown to Aragorn, but I guess there's no way around it, since that's how it played in the movie.

Author's reply

Thank you for restoring Faramir to the coronation scene, as the Steward! I still don't care for Gimli's bearing the crown to Aragorn, but I guess there's no way around it, since that's how it played in the movie. *smiles* You're welcome - I love the movie but certain things did bother me about the scene - Faramir's absence in the ceremony being one of them. I also didn't really like it that Frodo was not the one to carry the crown but since this was an expansion on the movie scene I had to include it as it happened on screen... Thanks for commenting!