Mirkwoodmaiden
· 18 February 2020
· Chapter 26: Dust to Dust VI
Conquistadora!
I have dedicated myself to reading Books 1 & 2. I am now continuing with 3. All I can say is Wow. The scope and scale of this is truly magnificent. The last chapters have been devastating but brilliantly written!! This review is inadequate to convey how much I love this story.
MM.
Author's reply
Thanks! I'm just sorry it takes me soooooo long to post updates, but I promise there are lots of plans. So glad you're enjoying it! :D
mystarlight
· 24 November 2019
· Chapter 26: Dust to Dust VI
Wonderful loyalty of Thranduil's army. Wonder if he was really summoned somehow by Sauron to show him his losses.
mystarlight
· 24 November 2019
· Chapter 25: Dust to Dust V
Thranduil is so stubborn that his determination can be only admired. Brilliantly written fight for his life done by his brothers.
Author's reply
Thank you!
mystarlight
· 24 November 2019
· Chapter 24: Dust to Dust IV
I reread this chapter and the scene when weak Galadhrim is trying anchor fading Thranduil is really heart breaking. He loves Thranduil like a member of his family.
mystarlight
· 17 November 2019
· Chapter 26: Dust to Dust VI
I enjoyed closing my eyes and imagining the whole series of events. Your prose is so incredibly vivid and lush that it's easy to let yourself float away into the story. Thank you so much for sharing.
Author's reply
You are very welcome. :)
mystarlight
· 17 November 2019
· Chapter 25: Dust to Dust V
Not Seratharon:(. At least Thranduil was with him in last moments. Why do they not discuss the attack when Oropher died? I thought Thranduil will ask for explanation.
mystarlight
· 17 November 2019
· Chapter 24: Dust to Dust IV
It is one of the best stories about Thranduil I have ever read!!!
Author's reply
Thank you! <3 <3 <3
mystarlight
· 17 November 2019
· Chapter 23: Dust to Dust III
I enjoy every single scene in your story. Breathtaking battle scenes and Thranduil's hesitation and fear are brilliantly written.
mystarlight
· 17 November 2019
· Chapter 22: Dust to Dust II
Can't wait to find out why Gil Galad was waiting.
mystarlight
· 17 November 2019
· Chapter 21: Dust to Dust
I hope Gwaelas will survive. Interesting idea that Sauron created orcs with Elves posed by evil such as kinslaying.
mystarlight
· 17 November 2019
· Chapter 20: Banners Unfurled II
Fantastic, deeply engaging story. The world is captivating world, filled with complex characters and their intricate and layered relationships.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 19: Banners Unfurled
Noooo!!! The wedding will be put off again.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 18: The World Is Changed II
It is so sad that such wonderful moments are disturbed by such bad news. Love your idea about Sylvan army, royal guards and Thranduil's powers.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 17: The World Is Changed
At last engagement and a child!!! Suspect it is fall of Numenor.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 16: Echoes In the Dark
The story is amazing. I love the characters, the development, the pacing, all of it. Thank you so much for sharing.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 15: The Shadow Falls III
Marvelous story.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 14: The Shadow Falls II
Oropher's dilemma is really well presented. On the one hand he is right:Silvan army would be crashed to dust on the other hand how could they not help other Elves?
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 13: The Shadow Falls
Hope Thranduil and Lindoriel will be betrothed soon.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 12: Over the Mountains IX
It is difficult to put this story down. Hope Celeborn will manage to escape somehow.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 11: Over the Mountains VIII
What an amazing intrigue Annatar created. Love fighting Thranduil :D
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 10: Over the Mountains VII
A gripping and thoughtful tale from beginning to end. I am glad that I have the whole story or I would go crazy waiting for update. Thank you so much for your story.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 9: Over the Mountains VI
Extraordinary story!!!
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 8: Over the Mountains V
You are incredible storyteller. I am not able to stop reading. Well written, page turner , great characters.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 7: Over the Mountains IV
The clash between Thranduil and Annatar is perfectly written. This scene mekes me wonder if Annatar predicts that Thranduil can be a worthy opponent just like Celeborn predicted he would be a better king than Oropher. I am a bit surprised that Glorfindel seems to trust him though.This story is just epic and visionary. It takes the series as a whole from being very good, to being great.I am in the seventh heaven you are going to continue.
mystarlight
· 16 November 2019
· Chapter 6: Over the Mountains III