While the Ring went south... by Thundera Tiger
Lera · 18 September 2003 · Chapter 1: December 30, 3018
This is my second time reading this story. I adored it the first time which is why I came back. I think Gandalf's thoughts on the bet were very funny. i enjoyed seeing into his mind especially on Boramir. I find Boramir to be a very interesting and complex character.
Hai · 23 August 2003 · Chapter 21: January 12, 3019 (Morning)
It was a wonderful story and you gave a lot to put into the gaps! Thank you for all the time I'm sure you invested in this. I will eventually get around to reading your sequels. I liked how you developed Gimli and Legolas's relationship, even though I don't usually care for stories about them I found this most delightful! Thank you! I also liked how you developed Boromir though I more thought him curious then predjudice (sp?) around other races. I hope to see him a little more firendly in the sequels, and he seems to be at a good start! Thank you for such a lovely entertaining story! The path over the mountain is one of my favorite sequences, thanks!
Hai · 22 August 2003 · Chapter 6: January 3, 3019 (Day)
I have to stop here before I have time to finish the rest, but I did want to let you know that I was finding this to be wonderful entertainment! All the things Tolkien can go into detail over and skips all those days they were traveling. Thank you for the lovely ideas as to what might have happened. I laughed out loud, which is something as I usually don't when reading something on my own, at Pippin's last little comment "Pippin the Elf" now that would be something. Thank you for what you have written and I look forward to getting a chance to finish it.