Ada Knows Best by Misty

Reviews (17)

Write a review

Larner · 1 April 2006 · Chapter 8

Yes, both sides have learned from this, for Aragorn has managed to prove himself the warrior he must be and the decent individual he must be as well, and Elrond has reassured this beloved fosterling that he does well. Thanks for the story--have enjoyed it.

Author's reply

I do like writing the loving father-son relationship between Elrond and Aragorn. In this story, Elrond has to come to terms with the fact that Aragorn is growing up, but he still has to reassure his son that he did well with everything he was facing. I think it is due to the way Elrond handles things that Aragorn doesn't get completely overwhelmed by everything later in his life. Yes, Aragorn has an inner strength, but Elrond nurtured that strength and allowed him to grow into the man who would one day be king. I'm glad you enjoyed it. Misty

Yelena_of_Baelandalai · 1 April 2006 · Chapter 1

I must admit, I'm slightly worried for Estel. I'd always wondered about Aragorn as a kid, and I think I'm going to enjoy this story. I sense an argument on the horizon between Estel and his "brothers". Question: Wouldn't he see Arwen as his sister if he saw Elrond as Ada and the twins as brothers?

Author's reply

Well, I hope you do continue to read and enjoy this story. There is definitely cause for you to worry over Estel as the story continues. As for the argument, you'll just have to keep reading to find out what happens between Estel and the twins. As for seeing Arwen as a sister, he didn't meet her until he was twenty, so he would not have grown up thinking of her as a sister. For some reason, Elrond and the twins never even mentioned her. In the appendices, Tolkien mentions that Elrond came to see Estel as a son, so in my mind, it makes sense that Estel would see Elrond as a father and the twins as his brothers. I imagine that Aragorn did have many mixed feelings when he fell in love with Arwen, knowing that she was the daughter of his foster father and the sister of the elves he saw as his brothers. But all of the stories I write that include the twins have Aragorn being their 'little brother'.

Elflingimp · 30 March 2006 · Chapter 7

Please more, this is so good!

Author's reply

Thanks, there's one more chapter left, to kind of wrap things up.

Larner · 30 March 2006 · Chapter 7

It is a time to reflect on what's happened. What Estel has done has been to blood him as a warrior, which I would hope would not be the easiest of roles for him to accept, although it is a most necessary one. But he's done exceedingly well both originally and in his accepting the responsibilities his actions have brought on him.

Author's reply

Yes, Estel will have to come to terms with everything that's happened. It won't be easy for him at all, but he'll have Elrond and the twins to help him through it. Elladan never wanted him to have to do the actual killing, but Estel could not allow the others to take all the responsibility for it, since it was his actions that made it necessary.

Jay of Lasgalen · 30 March 2006 · Chapter 6

And there I was, thinking that with the arrival of the cavalry (sorry, Elves), the story would be ending! Poor Estel - this will be a hard lesson for him. I don't think Elladan should leave him to do all the killing, though.

Author's reply

Oh no, the story doesn't end there! There is a lot that has to be dealt with after Estel's rescue plans. And don't worry, Elladan would never leave his little brother to do all the killing. He's much more protective of him than that.

Larner · 29 March 2006 · Chapter 6

It is unfortunately only right Estel should accept the more horrid responsibilities along with the joyful ones; and it will aid him in the life he is to face in the future.

Author's reply

Yes, though it is a terrible thing, Estel is having to face the consequences of his actions. But it is moments like these that shape who a person becomes, and I think he turned out all right. Of course, no one can came away from something like this unscathed. He'll be dealing with this for awhile.

Larner · 29 March 2006 · Chapter 5

To do as well as he did in the limited amount of time available was quite the feat. Now, who will rescue the rescuer? And LOVED the release of the hornet's nest on them! Clever Aragorn, using all he can find at the time to rescue his brothers!

Author's reply

Yes, Estel proved himself to be quite the tactician. But even the best plans can go awry, as Estel found out. He is certainly in need of some help now. As for the hornet's nest, that part kind of wormed its way into the story. It wasn't an element I had planned ahead of time. But it certainly worked well for Aragorn, didn't it?

eliza61 · 28 March 2006 · Chapter 4

I bet Estel did not bargain on all this adventure! Really good story Misty, can't wait to see if Estel comes thru or gets capture with the rest of them. Poor Elrond, this must be one of the times when you can't figure out if you want to hug your child or choke them. LOL Post soon

Author's reply

No, this is not what Estel thought he'd be facing when he took off to follow the others. You're right, I can only imagine the thoughts that cross Elrond's mind when he sees the message Estel wrote. I can imagine it would be quite a mix of emotions. The next chapter is on the way.

Larner · 27 March 2006 · Chapter 4

Well, of COURSE his mind is devious--look at who have trained him for the past thirteen years! Two devious twins and one of the greatest Elven warriors that ever walked through Arda! Now to see how his distraction works!

Author's reply

True, with the twins and the other elves as his teachers, he would have to be quite devious. But with one of the twins commenting on it, you know things could get very...interesting. ;-)

Pippin · 27 March 2006 · Chapter 4

hello my name is pippin, this is an interesing story i am exited to here the rest. have a good day

Author's reply

Hi, Thanks for the review. I'm glad you're enjoying the story. The next chapter will be posted very soon. Thanks again.

Jay of Lasgalen · 27 March 2006 · Chapter 4

I really like resourceful Estel here. He's proving that he's capable of planning and plotting a rescue attempt single handed, and has even managed to warn his brothers. So why do I think something will go wrong, and that he'll need that antidote?

Author's reply

I liked writing Estel as someone who could use what he has been taught in order to do what must be done, even as he's scared to death to do it. As for the antidote...well, no healer worth his salt would make up a poison to be used in the manner he's planning without making up the antidote as well, just in case.

Larner · 26 March 2006 · Chapter 3

A good thing the other son of Elrond is on his way, isn't it? An interesting description of their predicamate.

Author's reply

Yes, the twins could definitely use some help at this point. Getting out on their own isn't looking that promising, is it?

Jay of Lasgalen · 26 March 2006 · Chapter 3

*Sigh* I knew the twins were in trouble. Which one is in the worst condition - Elladan with a head injury and concussion, or Elrohir with a leg injury and unable to walk? I like their mutual worry over each other. Jay

Author's reply

Well, is this living up to the promise of twin angst? *g* They're both in pretty bad shape, but of course, they are each more concerned over the other.

Larner · 25 March 2006 · Chapter 2

To recognize the dead Elf must have been terrible, and the implications are certainly worse, to think of Elladan, Elrohir, and the other two in the hands of the orcs. Hopefully he will find them soon. And I do think Elrond made the best decision.

Author's reply

Yes, Elrond really had to fight his fatherly instincts to make the decision not to go after Estel, but he knew he had to let him grow up sometime. Though I'm thinking that at this point, Estel wished he had listened to his father and stayed home. He is realizing just how out of his depth he is in this set of circumstances.

Jay of Lasgalen · 25 March 2006 · Chapter 2

Well, I was right about disaster befalling him. The trouble is, even bigger disaster has befallen the twins :( Does this mean twin angst? Lots and lots of twin angst? I do hope so! Jay

Author's reply

Well, there will be twin angst... *eg* You're right about the twins being in more trouble right now than Estel. This time, they won't be able to protect him and keep him out of trouble. So what will he do next? You'll just have to wait and see.

Jay of Lasgalen · 25 March 2006 · Chapter 1

Why do I get the feeling that some disaster is about to befall him? I hope the twins are on hand! Great start. Jay

Author's reply

Well, your feeling is quite correct, disaster is looming on the horizon. But disaster for whom? *eg* Thanks.

Larner · 24 March 2006 · Chapter 1

The young do this SO often--try to sneak out unobserved.

Author's reply

Yes, Estel will soon discover why his actions might not have been his best idea.