mystarlight · 9 February 2020 · Chapter 28: Hands of a King
Love your description of battles!!!! Now I an really looking forward for the king in the battle!!!!Must buy some treats and vanilla coffee to celebrate reading :D
We Were Young Once ~ III by Conquistadora
Reviews (196)
mystarlight · 7 February 2020 · Chapter 28: Hands of a King
I really miss your updates.
Author's reply
Sorry! :( I have been thinking about all of you as I try to drum up another few updates, but both chapters-in-progress involve complicated battles so I've been brushing up my battlefield tactics with lots of internet research! They're coming, I promise. :)
Starlight and Moonlight · 27 January 2020 · Chapter 28: Hands of a King
Conquistadora, I am so glad that you have begun to upload again. I read all three parts of "We Were Young Once" for the first time last year, and I am planning on reading them again this year. Thanks for your amazing contributions to the world of Tolkien fan fiction! I know that this is a rough time for everyone with Christopher Tolkien's death, but stories like the ones that you write have helped me through that. May we all be united because of this wonderous and magical world that J.R.R. Tolien created. With blessings from America, Lanya
Author's reply
Thank you! I have many more plans, but sadly I write extremely slowly. Thoughtful reviews like yours are highly motivating!
Calenlassiel · 12 January 2020 · Chapter 0: Dust and Memory
I have just recently become a Thranduil fan. I am currently reading We Were Young Once II. During the past Christmas I read your paper on Thranduil and agree with every letter you typed. I also did my own research after reading your thesis to check the facts your presented. Thank you for blowing away all of the fandom fanon myths out there. As for "We Were Young Once" series your writing skills proclaim you a master story teller. When LOTR movies came out in the early 2000s I knew nothing of Tolkien's works. After going crazy over the movies I began my love affair with Tolkien's Books. Now in some ways I wish I had never seen the movies. They do no justice to JRRT's works. Well, my dear Conquistadora this post is for you. Thank you for writing a serious tale about our favorite Greenwood Boy... ;) Seriously, if you ever get writers block or need a smile just know YOUR fans are out here to cheer you on... Hugs, Cal
Author's reply
Thank you!!! I just write the kind of thing I would want to read, and its very exciting when others enjoy it too. Thanks so much for all your kind encouragement. I promise there is another chapter in the works, but it's going to be a long one and I want it to be good. ;)
Jo · 6 January 2020 · Chapter 28: Hands of a King
Wow! I hope you continue with the story; your writing is remarkable. Cheers to 2020!
Author's reply
Thank you! I hope to be able to devote more time to this story this year. :)
mystarlight · 9 December 2019 · Chapter 21: Hopeless Courage III
I reread this chapter and although I knew what to expect I was mesmerised once again. Fast pace and action packed made me forget about the whole world. Love Thranduil's wrath and he really acts as the greatest king. The idea of his wife gathering their people in Valinor is wonderful. You are a brilliant story-teller!!!
Author's reply
Thank you! You inspire me every time you leave a review. :D
CandissD · 3 December 2019 · Chapter 28: Hands of a King
Thank you so much for the updates! I just finished catching up and cannot wait to read more! :)
Author's reply
You're welcome! All these enthusiastic reviewers have me excited about writing again. :D
mystarlight · 3 December 2019 · Chapter 28: Hands of a King
Every time I think this story can't be better you prove me I am wrong!!! You made me feel like nothing else mattered but reading this story! I am with Thranduil in healing Halls and watch him help the ill. What happens to the boy and a father? Will any dragons appear? Excellent characters, loads of action and a deep well developed world I do not want to leave. Read this chapter during my break as waiting for going home seemed like ages to me:D.
Author's reply
So glad you enjoyed it! I was thinking of you when I was finishing it up last night. :D
mystarlight · 30 November 2019 · Chapter 27: Holding the North V
WONDERFUL, exquisitely written and thoroughly engrossing adventure! You are such a talented writer.
Author's reply
Thank you!
mystarlight · 30 November 2019 · Chapter 26: Holding the North IV
Compelling story!!! It is a must-read for people who love Tolkien's world.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 25: Holding the North III
Unforgettable story.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 24: Holding the North II
It kept me so involved I want to immerse myself in this world and never leave.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 22: Winds of Ruin
Wonderful story about Thranduil's new crown. Once again I am captivated by a new obstacle. Action-packed and full of endless twists I fell in love with this story.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 21: Hopeless Courage III
Breathtaking battle scenes!!! This story has caught my attention and refuses to let go (not that I want it :D)
Author's reply
Thanks for all the great reviews! You are unquestionably the most prolific reviewer I've ever had. Always exciting to find these surprises in my inbox! Thanks to you, the next chapter is well under way. :D
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 20: Hopeless Courage II
This story keeps me turning pages. Loved how suspenseful and full of action this story is. I am on the edge of my seat and I can’t wait for what happens next.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 19: Hopeless Courage
This world is rich, has depth, and is full of angst and joy, with some awesome battles thrown in. I find myself fully immersed each time I open a story.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 18: The Darkest Night III
I definitely couldn't get enough of this story. Wonderful characters development.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 16: The Darkest Night
This chapter made me cry. Poor Thranduil. I was so sure she will sail to Valinor.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 15: The Challenge
I am happy that she survived but Noruvion is right they really need the king not the martyr. I didn't like Mithrandir at their first meeting: he was so arrogant.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 14: The Storm Breaks
This story offers a cinematic adventure. Characters are really memorable and terrific.
mystarlight · 29 November 2019 · Chapter 13: Whispers in the Dark VII
A truly amazing read.
mystarlight · 26 November 2019 · Chapter 12: Whispers in the Dark VI
This chapter left me breathless again. He managed to light the fire with his will only!!!
mystarlight · 26 November 2019 · Chapter 11: Whispers in the Dark V
Thranduil is really busy. Terrific story.
mystarlight · 26 November 2019 · Chapter 10: Whispers in the Dark IV
It is a must-read for people who love Tolkien's world.
mystarlight · 25 November 2019 · Chapter 9: Whispers in the Dark III
I am mesmerised by the plot. Finally Thranduil can suspect Sauron's return. Love council meetings. His nightmares about Mordor are well written. Is he imagining Sauron's laugh or Sauron somehow left a mark which allows him to do that?