Reviews (321)

KathyG · 11 June 2021 · Chapter 17: Good King Elessar: Part 1, Hither Page and Stand by Me

You know, Dreamflower, this story could easily be posted as a stand-alone.

KathyG · 12 March 2021 · Chapter 17: Good King Elessar: Part 1, Hither Page and Stand by Me

You know, Dreamflower, since "Good King Elessar" is a 6-chapter story, you ought to post it as a separate story. Then everyone who wants to read it could find it easily. It is a nice story--too nice to be hidden within any of your story anthologies! =)

Larner · 23 January 2018 · Chapter 38: The Search for the Perfect Gift

Am so far behind in making comments and reading here! Again, thank you so much for this story--it filled the bill so well! In the end Frodo found that out of the mouths of babes....

Andrea · 18 January 2018 · Chapter 38: The Search for the Perfect Gift

A very wise person showed me that the things you like the most are the best things you can give to people you love, because if you love it, they will, too. How wonderful! I like this very much. Wisdom does not always require a long life to gain it. But like Frodo I doubt that Folco is aware of that, too ;-)

Antane · 3 January 2018 · Chapter 38: The Search for the Perfect Gift

What a sweet story! I love it. :) Happy New Year! Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

KathyG · 3 January 2018 · Chapter 17: Good King Elessar: Part 1, Hither Page and Stand by Me

You should post this one as a separate story! It would be perfect for that.

KathyG · 3 January 2018 · Chapter 38: The Search for the Perfect Gift

I love how Folco helped Frodo decide what would be a perfect gift to give to Bilbo. Plus Bilbo also received all those other gifts from his other relatives and friends! =) Are you going to post this on Fanfiction.net, too?

Antane · 30 December 2016 · Chapter 37: A New Year's Game of the Shire

That's a fun game - thanks for sharing! Happy Yule! Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Larner · 28 December 2016 · Chapter 37: A New Year's Game of the Shire

Oh, how delightful a game, and so appropriate for a Shire Yule!

Andrea · 27 December 2016 · Chapter 37: A New Year's Game of the Shire

Don't look for it behind; A new one we must find! That is indeed a very nice game and a lot of fun! I hope you have had a merry Christmas and I wish you a happy New Year!

Antane · 24 January 2016 · Chapter 36: How Yule Came to Gondor

The hobbity version is a much better way to celebrate - dear me, how depressing it must have been before just focusing on much you've screwed up. New Year's Eve is my favorite holiday because there is the excitement of a new year coming and all you can do it. I don't do anything to celebrate except in my heart and mind being excited and that is best. Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Andrea · 24 January 2016 · Chapter 36: How Yule Came to Gondor

A very nice story. I'm quite sure the people of Gondor will love this new tradition. I also like the newest carol. But my favourite still is the lighting of the Yule Log. The day is short; the night is long. Against the dark we sing this song-- Let our hearts be filled with light And may the world again grow bright...

UTfrog · 19 January 2016 · Chapter 36: How Yule Came to Gondor

I really enjoyed this story. The litany was beautiful. Thank you.

nancylea57@yahoo.com · 18 January 2016 · Chapter 35: An Unexpected Yule Bounty

Loved the story the first time I read it. Loved the fact that this read through reminds me of one more cold evening fill-up, now where did I leave the grocery list.

Lindelea · 22 December 2015 · Chapter 35: An Unexpected Yule Bounty

Oh, lovely! I want to try this. Maybe this will be a new Christmas tradition...

Andrea · 6 December 2015 · Chapter 35: An Unexpected Yule Bounty

"Sam said you were splendid, sir, and well, I-I reckon he's right" A wonderful story. I liked it very much, especially young Till!

Eruherdiriel · 4 December 2015 · Chapter 35: An Unexpected Yule Bounty

Awwww. Til is very cute. I enjoyed this a lot. Thanks for sharing! ~Eruherdiriel

Antane · 3 December 2015 · Chapter 35: An Unexpected Yule Bounty

I loved this story! Horray for simpler times and the joy of giving. Love Frodo and Bilbo's tradition of dusting the mantle and the interactions between Till and Frodo :) Nsmarie, God bless, Antane :)

Lindelea · 5 January 2015 · Chapter 34: Eucatastrophe: Yuletide in Annúminas

Such a lovely celebration! I adored Frodo's rescue of Pippin, lol! (Is that what they call "tit for tat"?) As always, so many little details bring the story to life, like the fact that a feast was managed, that was truly a feast, yet did not deplete the food store in view of the weather emergency. Beregond! How I love to catch a glimpse of him. And Bergil, of course. And somehow I find this AU quite comforting.

Larner · 1 January 2015 · Chapter 34: Eucatastrophe: Yuletide in Annúminas

So delighted to have this as my Yule gift, and joy to you in the coming year! Love the poem, too. May this new year be filled with accomplishment for all of us! (And loved having Frodo included!)

Antane · 1 January 2015 · Chapter 34: Eucatastrophe: Yuletide in Annúminas

Great fun for them all! Gimli will be sorry that he missed it. That would have been been the whole surviving Fellowship. I am glad Faramir was there too. :) Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Antane · 1 January 2015 · Chapter 33: Good-bye, Old Year, Good-bye!

Happy Yule! Thanks for a hobbity song here! :) Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

shirebound · 1 January 2015 · Chapter 33: Good-bye, Old Year, Good-bye!

May our joys be bright, And our sorrows be light *beams* What lovely New Year greeting.

Garnet Took · 1 January 2015 · Chapter 33: Good-bye, Old Year, Good-bye!

I really love this one. This sums up all my feelings as the year changes. I could so see singing this. :)

KathyG · 1 January 2015 · Chapter 33: Good-bye, Old Year, Good-bye!

LOL! Yeah, that's right. Yule and New Year are one and the same for hobbits; there's no discrepancy between the 2 holidays as there is for us.