Reviews (60)

Andrea · 1 May 2008 · Chapter 8: Walking Between Worlds

Wow! That was written beautifully! You could feel the magic surrounding Paladin and Pippin. Pearl's review made me curious. Did that voice belong to the oak tree or to a spirit that lives in the tree but is able to leave it? I don't know many faerie stories. Anyway, Paladin has entered the faerie world now and I'm quite sure he will find his son. But I'm eager to know more about the mysterious Took ancestor who met Eolande, for example his name ;-)

Agape4Gondor · 30 April 2008 · Chapter 1: Tulip

What an absolutely delightful tale! I'm so glad I found it. I just loved the whole thing - but especially WHY Pip needed two baths. Well written shenanigans... And I cannot believe his sister didn't scream when the eggs broke. Great fun! Thanks so much!

shirebound · 30 April 2008 · Chapter 8: Walking Between Worlds

My goodness, the Magic just grows deeper and deeper. I wonder how much Pippin and his father will remember of this? But of course Tulip will remember everything. :)

Pearl Took · 30 April 2008 · Chapter 8: Walking Between Worlds

oooo! Lovely!! Poor Paladin! I know the spirit means well, but as parent, I know he wants his lad, not strange teachings. I'm so glad Alfie is keeping an eye on Pippin :-) Wonderful as always,Cahtleen! MEWD!!

Golden · 29 March 2008 · Chapter 7: Along a Path of Light

Love it! Especially the scene with the music making creatures and Pip wondring where it comes from made a beautful, magic picture in my mind. The name you now picked out for the river is great too! Look forward to more! :)

Andrea · 28 March 2008 · Chapter 7: Along a Path of Light

Wow! If I counted right, we have now four different strands in this story: three search parties - and Pippin :) I'm impressed! I really hope that the forest was not tricking Paladin and sent him in the wrong direction. After all the forest and its inhabitants should have sensed that he is another one with faerie blood in his veins. And they know where his son is. So, the "cave search party" found Paladin's slingshot? LOL!!! Pippin and his father have indeed a lot in common ;-) I'm looking forward to reading more.

Larner · 27 March 2008 · Chapter 7: Along a Path of Light

Ah--the Faerie blood tells in this story, showing up in Paladin and Peregrin both. And we see that Merry wasn't the first one to find that cave! Paladin's catapult! Hooray! Soon the reunion will take place, and Pippin will return home to his home.

shirebound · 27 March 2008 · Chapter 7: Along a Path of Light

Oh my goodness, how suspenseful! The reunion is going to be so joyous when it finally comes. “They want you to know how much they appreciate the music they have heard you make, Peregrin. You sing like no other they have heard before, with a voice that is sweet and clear, and that rings with joy and purity.” That's lovely.

Pearl Took · 27 March 2008 · Chapter 7: Along a Path of Light

All so very well done, Cathleen!! And you are very welcome :-) I love the things that are happening with Pippin and the faerie folk. I really liked how you handled the business with the small cave. Good suspense and a wonderful surprise resolution! Like father . . .

Pearl Took · 27 January 2008 · Chapter 6: A Faerie's Garden

Most curious! Paladin didn't actually find Tulip . . . did he? Pip is in the woods . . . isn't he? I really sympathize with Merry and all the family that is with him. They are so frightened. Looking forward to more :-)

Golden · 26 January 2008 · Chapter 6: A Faerie's Garden

Another great Chapter! :D I loved this from beginning to end and how your decribe this small earth fairy is wonderful. I wonder...you think when Pip is grown, like maybe after the Quest and not as "innocent" as before with all the evil he has seen, how would it be, when he and Roswhen meet again?

Andrea · 25 January 2008 · Chapter 6: A Faerie's Garden

Wow! I just discovered this story today and I read it in one go! Roshwen seems to be a lot like Pippin! Alfie, who might be a leader of her kind, reacts differently. And I would trust her to bring Pippin back to his own world. For he left his world when he brushed the primroses against that huge stone, right? I agree with Pippin that Tulip sounds a lot like his mother! But that's exactly what he needs at times ;-) Paladin is on the right track, and I loved it to see that his "Sight" reassured him that his son was in no danger. I only wonder what Saradoc and his companions will find! They follow the wrong direction, don't they? Well, we'll see ... Thank you for another wonderful story :)

Larner · 25 January 2008 · Chapter 6: A Faerie's Garden

At least Merry is thinking on what Pippin might have done; and with the practicality of Hobbits Eglantine is planning for all contingencies. Love the search as being followed by Pal, and his trust in his Sight. Now, to find Tulip like that.... Is Pippin in the throes of his own vision granted by the sight? Now I'm wondering just where Pippin WILL be found! And I love the look at all the small guardians Pippin is meeting. Perhaps he will find it that much the easier in the distant future when he sees Frodo leave Middle Earth, knowing that so many will be watching over his beloved older cousin.

shirebound · 25 January 2008 · Chapter 6: A Faerie's Garden

My goodness, I hope someone believes Pippin's story when he tells it. What an unusual adventure for him and Tulip.

ruby · 13 January 2008 · Chapter 5: Alfie

Please write more soon! I think Tulip the pig is adorable and it's neat that you don't really say that she doesn't talk to Pippin!

Queens Reader · 21 October 2007 · Chapter 5: Alfie

This is so much fun! Can't wait to see what happes next! In the meantime, it's back to knitting my own little Tulip. ; ) QR

Golden · 20 October 2007 · Chapter 5: Alfie

Finally! :D Love the Chapter! Pip and the little fairy are so sweet, but glad her mom is there. More please! *sits back waiting* *g*

Larner · 19 October 2007 · Chapter 5: Alfie

Oh, wonderful! So, Alfie(?) has come to stop Rhoswen from capturing poor Pippin forever in the Faerie Halls, has she? And just managed to get there in time to stop him from eating faerie food! Bless her. Now the rest have the chance to find him! Poor little lad, though, realizing he's just lost what promised to be a wonderful feast! Heh!

Pearl Took · 18 October 2007 · Chapter 5: Alfie

I think Pip is not the only one in trouble with a parent ;-) Wonderful and more wonderful! I want a Tulip! She's adorable!

shirebound · 18 October 2007 · Chapter 5: Alfie

Oh my, what a magical tale! I'm glad everyone is searching, and I wonder who will find him first? He and Tulip will be *ready* for a feast by that time. :)

Golden · 13 August 2007 · Chapter 4: Rhoswen

Great Chapter. Finally she spoke to him. I can´t wait how it will continue. I don´t think Rhoswen is evil, so I not really fear for Pip ( well a bit maybe *g*), but I am veeeeeeery curious on what he will see and learn and of course how he comes back to his family in the end.

Pearl Took · 9 August 2007 · Chapter 4: Rhoswen

I'm so glad she has finally spoken to Pippin :) I love your descriptions of her part of the woods, all the brighter colors and everything seeming fresher somehow. Poor Tulip! Eglantine really did put part of herself in that knitted piglet! Perhaps, she was thinking it would be a way to keep an eye on her rascal of a son ;-) This is such fun!

Larner · 8 August 2007 · Chapter 4: Rhoswen

Hmm. Time can move strangely in the fairy halls.

shirebound · 8 August 2007 · Chapter 4: Rhoswen

Oh dear, I hope Pippin won't be irretrievably lost! He seems very deep into the spell of faerie, and is now in another realm altogether. Tulip is such a wonderful companion. :)

Dreamflower · 8 August 2007 · Chapter 4: Rhoswen

Ah! This came out very nicely! I am very curious to know what the faerie wants with Pippin, and why she chose to lure him away. And of course, I'm concerned about his poor family, frantic with worry!