Reviews (1,565)

6336 · 10 February 2010 · Chapter 96: The Quest Begins

Hi Fiondil, Sorry I havn't been reviewing lately R.L. has been a bit hectic. I feel for Glorfi, I used to get motion sickness as a youngster plus I suffer from 'good old fashioned sick headaches'(direct quote from my Dr.!) so I know just how he feels, you just want it to end! Hm, so he now has a companion, just who or what is he, not what he appears to be that is certain! Gee what an original name for a dog! Huggs, Lynda

Kaylee Tonks-Lupin · 9 February 2010 · Chapter 96: The Quest Begins

Here I am Atar Fiondil! It has been too long *hugs* I've been reading all along I promise, it's just that I've had ick computer problems/lots of school issues making reviewing difficult. YAY Glorfi is going to find his answers! But who is this ellon with a dog? *suspicious* My money is on him NOT being a real ellon at all. Orome perhaps? Ulmo? Hm. He did say Ulmo. Maybe he was teasing Glorfi. Or, or or!!! *giggles* Maybe...maybe he's /Earendil/ in disguise! yes! after all, he's a mariner. Why not? And who else would know how to find Elwing's tower? ...'kay, maybe I'm too hyper to make sense. *lol* but I was just thinking that maybe it might make some sense. After all, with Glorfi usually the most insane things happen so why not that? (I know, I know, as a Teler he'd look nothing like Earendil, but that's why I said a disguise. Or TILION! yes a Maia, why not. :) Hee, I'm starting to sound like I used to when I first reviewed your fics. *lol* sorry for the insane hyper-ness.) (Oh and I hear you're back states-side now! how are you doing???) Tye-melin tenn'Ambar-metta, Atar Fiondil. Kaylee

ellie · 9 February 2010 · Chapter 96: The Quest Begins

I feel so sorry for Glorfy with his seasickness. I guess elves aren't invincible are they? I am very curious about his new friend. I think it is a maia or a Vala in disguise and it seems he may suspect such a thing as well. At least the guy is good with fire on wet days. That could be handy! And a traveling companion could be just what Glorfy needs right now. Of course you are going to make us wait and see...

Sunny · 8 February 2010 · Chapter 96: The Quest Begins

So Glorfindel isn’t a sailor. Fair enough – there must be _something_ at which he is abysmal. But I hope he won’t stay _quite_ so hopeless in a boat. Or else there might develop an AU where Glorfy can’t stand the idea of tossing his cookies all the way to Ennor. But we all know he _did_ cross over, so I suspect he will have thoroughly stocked up on ginger in various forms before his voyage ;-) The first Interesting Thing has happened – Glorfindel has acquired a sidekick for his journey north. I assume he is really an Elf – while the Valar are likely to keep close tabs on him still, any Maia watchers are probably more likely to float around unclad. Then again, given the Valar and their interest in him, I suppose anything is possible...

Tari · 8 February 2010 · Chapter 93: Return to Aman

Something bothers me about this leave takilng. I don't know what it is, but I feel a strong forboding. I hope I'm wrong.

Hel · 7 February 2010 · Chapter 95: Glorfindel in Alqualondë

Privacy is a nice thing but those two overdo it a bit. I wonder what the reasons for this hiding is. They must be really good the Valar aid them that much. I ask myself if Earendil remembers Glorfindel from his childhood in Gondolin and his death at the flight? And if he is glad to see him again?

Larner · 3 February 2010 · Chapter 95: Glorfindel in Alqualondë

I find myself wondering why it is that Elwing's tower is so far removed not only from civilisation but even from thought? Now, to learn the answer to these questions!

Sunny · 1 February 2010 · Chapter 95: Glorfindel in Alqualondë

Huh. “We don’t know exactly where the tower is located.” And the conditions imposed on those who went there to build the tower. It makes me wonder just who was behind those conditions - and why. Whether it was Eärendil and Elwing who wanted to protect their privacy, or the Valar who decided on it for their own reasons. It also makes me wonder just how interesting the journey north is going to be.

ellie · 1 February 2010 · Chapter 95: Glorfindel in Alqualondë

So, did the following mean that Manwe asked the Lindar not to go or did it mean that, even though invited, the Lindar did not attend? I'm sleep deprived so sorry for a stupid question. "Certainly when the Light went out and the Calacirya darkened it was a frightening experience for us all, for none of us went to Ilmarin at Lord Manwë’s behest, so we were unaware until well after the fact of what occurred..." Poor Glorfy just doesn't get any breaks, does he? Of rouse he has to go to a hidden place and who knows how long it will take him to get there...not fair. I wish the Valar would just tell the poor guy what he wants to know, but I guess it's journey and not the destination, huh? I fear a long and lonely time for him.

Hel · 31 January 2010 · Chapter 94: Going Separate Ways

So they all have their own plans and projects after the council is postponed. Hopefully not for good. I wonder if Glorfindel gets the answers he seeks or if the answers he finds will be what he imagined them to be. I fear he will be a bit disapointed in the end. Varda´s reaction to holding the council in Ilmarien was . . . interesting. But I think if she orders them to clean their shoes before entering, they will shurely follow the order. But nice to know how much the Valar meddle with the lives of the elves again.

Tari · 27 January 2010 · Chapter 91: Council Meeting

Isn't it sad that some of the Elves on Tol Eressëa are so hard hearted. They really did it this time. Who knows what will happen to them next; they might even experience a visit from some of the Valar. That would shake them up a bit.

Kitty · 25 January 2010 · Chapter 94: Going Separate Ways

So Glorfindel is finally going to find answers, or at least some. Good. And I was glad the others took his plans as they did; I was a bit worried they would protest, and he would not have taken that well. Finrod did a great job as big brother, but I guess Arafinwë is right; Glorfindel is growing up, and Finrod has probably to adjust to that change in their relationship. Though now I am wondering what the poor ellon will say when he finally learns that Glorfindel will return to Middle-earth. Somehow I think Finrod will not be happy, even if he has had some centuries with his gwador until then. Varda's reaction to the idea of the council held in Ilmarin or Valmar left me laughing. Most of these children are adults, after all. And tracking mud all over the place *snort* First, that's unlikely, and second, it would take only a second for the Valar or Maiar to remove that, so what's the problem? Like the idea of inviting the people of Angobel, council or no :-)

Larner · 25 January 2010 · Chapter 94: Going Separate Ways

A nice time of transition here. Yes, Glorfindel returns to his own, as do the others. And Varda complains about possible mud? Heh!

ellie · 25 January 2010 · Chapter 94: Going Separate Ways

Finrod makes a good big brother and I feel sorry for him for the separation. I hope Glorfy gets things worked out for himself and learns whatever it is he is out to learn. It has got to be amazingly frustrating being reborn...

Sunny · 25 January 2010 · Chapter 94: Going Separate Ways

And now I understand that life in Alqualondë - and ponts further north - is going to get interesting. ;-) Varda sounds like a collector with a house full of the most delicate china and crystal, who is asked to be hostess for a preschooler's birthday party (lots of little kids on a sugar high - merely imagining it is exhausting!)

6336 · 25 January 2010 · Chapter 94: Going Separate Ways

I hope Glorfindel will find some of the answers he needs, he won't get all of them, just enough for him to have more! Why is Varda getting her knickers in a twist over the Children having their Council at Ilmarin, I don't think a lot of the Council members would be comfortable having it there. Valmar is a possibility or how about Lorien, don't think that would go down too well with Este though! I think they should pick a spot in the middle of the Calacyra and hold it there, the watch Mair should be able to keep them under control! Lynda

Kitty · 24 January 2010 · Chapter 93: Return to Aman

Hm ... it rankles that they have to leave in secret, though I have to agree that it's the sensible way. The danger of more trouble when crossing through the city would be too big. So, in the end, I was glad all went smoothly and they got on board and out of the harbour without any problems. I just hope Thorongoron will understand. It's not his fault that things went so bad, after all. Really look forward to know how things will proceed from here!

Kitty · 24 January 2010 · Chapter 92: To Keep Estel

Well, I had known the Elves can be devious, but not *that* devious! Never thought the Kings had that planned out. You've totally surprised me, Fiondil! After thinking it over, it might work, yes. Or at least I hope it does. While the people in Avallónë and Kortirion need a wake-up-call (or at least most of them), I am glad the Kings are willing to act differently about Tavrobel, Angobel and the Nandor who have proven to be mostly more sensible. While removing some of them to the mainland, it would probably not solve the problem with all of the others. So I hope they will come to their senses. Even more so as these common Elves with Ailinwë appear to be much more nice; I was glad they were allowed in. Ailinwë's story was touching. It must have been a comfort to Finrod to know that he even under these circumstances gave hope to the other prisoners in Tol Sirion. Hearing it from Námo is one thing, but to learn of this sort of experience is another matter altogether and probably much more impressive.

Tari · 20 January 2010 · Chapter 90: Kortirion

Could this be the calm before the storm? Things are just too peaceful as far as I'm concerned.

Anonymous · 18 January 2010 · Chapter 93: Return to Aman

Clever means of escape they came up with. Things were getting way out of hand. I just feel sorry for Thorongorn. I hope Finrod did get a message out to him so he'd understand. That Progress really was a huge whirlwind adventure! My goodness! I wonder how things will go in Aman now after all of that craziness on Tol Eressea.

6336 · 18 January 2010 · Chapter 93: Return to Aman

Well Arafinwe and Company have made a strtigic withdrawal, let's hope that those Tol Erresseans who welcomed them understand why they did it. The Solstice celebration is coming up, meybe they could have an impromptue Council then, even if it is only sitting round chatting! Now to find out what Mr. Unpredictable will do next! Lynda

Rhyselle · 18 January 2010 · Chapter 93: Return to Aman

An interesting chapter, but I see the potential for future issues with the so-called leadership of Kortirion--and, sadder, a possibility that Thorongon being put in a position where, if he truly does feel betrayed by the Amanian trick, to where he will be less supportive of Finrod. I would hope that friendship would prove stronger than politics, but... we'll see. Too bad that Finrod wasn't able to at least leave a note with Meriel to give to Thorongon, letting him know that it wasn't meant to be a personal affront. My laptop is still in the shop, so my reviews will continue to be dependent on getting onto someone else's machine, but I had to let you know that I was very pleased to get to read the new chapter!

ellie · 11 January 2010 · Chapter 92: To Keep Estel

Forgot to mention that I really liked the story Finrod was told about the influence his song of power had on the other captives. It had to have made him feel that his suffering and his feeble attempts at standing up against Sauron were worth it and brought some amount of good. I also think that news had to have had an impact on those Amanians around him. Finrod is such a cool elf... I'm glad you showed him some well-deserved gratitude.

Tari · 11 January 2010 · Chapter 89: Table Talk

I have to agree with the Elves as far as children are concerned. I believe they are a gift from God for however long either the parents or the child lives. No one person can "possess" another, no matter how much they might want to. I believe Galahdwen's attitude is merely a protective sheild. She does not want to be seen as vulnerable.

6336 · 11 January 2010 · Chapter 92: To Keep Estel

Oh, sneaky, very sneaky! I wonder if the people of Avallone knew just what Morocano was up to when he 'attacked'? It seems the people of Kortiron are not of the same mind as their leaders, just who elects who in the town councils and guilds? Perhaps the Kings should look to the population as a whole, of Tol Eressea for the members of the council and not just the, so called, leaders? Hope this makes sense, still a little sleepy, didn't get in until very early this morning, inventory! Retail, ah, what a life! Lynda