The Best Laid Plans..... by DADGAD

Reviews (32)

Write a review

Raksha The Demon · 9 July 2008 · Chapter 6: Can’t See the Wood for the Trees

Like, who would ever worry about a nice quiet forest. Trees are good for nothing but firewood anyhow. Very good characterisation of the soon-to-be-dead Orcs.

Author's reply

Raksha, Yes, its quite worrying how much i enjoy writing orc dialogue.....

Raksha The Demon · 9 July 2008 · Chapter 5: Famous Last Words

Wake up and smell the coffee, Angmar! One would think that the presence in Middle-earth of many beings who are not living men might trouble ol' tall-dark-and-noisome, what with Ents, Eagles, Elves, and one very peeved Wizard, but noooo. Just let that particular skinny, boyish Rider with the short friend get nice and close to you, now... I love the smell of Arrogance dissipating, along with funky ancient steel-spiked crowns, in the morning.

Author's reply

I have to confess, this was at least partly inspired by Elana's story 'No Living Man'. (SoA 1672)

Raksha The Demon · 9 July 2008 · Chapter 2: No Light in the Darkness

That's right, Red-Eye; just fume and froth about Isildur's spawn; don't even worry about the little creeping spies; they're beneath your grand notice. Orodruin doesn't need guarding... Sauron's obviously been reading his own press releases, or dispatches, for too long.

Author's reply

Thanks, Raksha. Actually, my view is that while Sauron in the second age was calculating, vindictive, but essentially in control of his emotions, by the third age he's utterly paranoid and insane. After all he's lost his fair body (in Numenor), his ring, and has had to regain his physical form by somehow feeding on the dead or their spirits. So he's probably not big on considered thought at this point....

Raksha The Demon · 9 July 2008 · Chapter 1: Dead Unlucky

And the thought of ancient Thorongil hobbling out of the mists of time with a pack of ghosts is just so ridiculous, isn't it... Great concept here!

eiluj · 9 July 2008 · Chapter 8: Tinder and Spark

Excellent use of meter. And you've caught the voice Tolkien used in The Hobbit.

Author's reply

Thanks eiluj! In some ways The Hobbit is still my favorite of the books, so I'm duly gratified by your review

eiluj · 9 July 2008 · Chapter 1: Dead Unlucky

Marvelous!

harrowcat · 9 July 2008 · Chapter 10: '...gang aft agley'

These are all great DADGAD. I liked the last one especially.

Author's reply

Thanks Harrowcat. I had done all the others and was not sure how to finish the series until I came up with this. Glad you like it!