Reviews (13)

Marianel · 8 March 2019 · Chapter 2: Love never ends

Such a beautyful story!I felt too what Eowyn must have done. My heart aches but at the same time it feels relief of finally Having seen someone so dear to Faramir.Im sure Eowyn and Finduilas would have loved each other despite their differences. Indeed it must be so good for Faramirs sake to know that his mother and father too loved him though jnfortunately he didnt show it much it seems. Dear Faramir... he always was one of my favourite charachters, he deserved so much more. Luckily you write about him what we get too little of in the books and movies though he married Eowyn- namely his happiness!

harrowcat · 7 November 2008 · Chapter 2: Love never ends

Great little tale Linda. Would have liked to see a little more of her fight to come back to Faramir and her children.

Raksha The Demon · 6 November 2008 · Chapter 2: Love never ends

Interesting conversation between Faramir's wife and his mother; it works well here, sort of an interlude between life and death. Hopefully Faramir will have a better relationship with his son than his father had with him. Excellent conclusion to the story!

Raksha The Demon · 6 November 2008 · Chapter 1: Roses have Thorns

I love the poetry selections with which you began the chapter - very appropriate. And of course, the plot thickens and danger threatens; Faramir hearing his long-dead mother's voice is a nice touch.

Estelcontar · 5 November 2008 · Chapter 2: Love never ends

I'm glad Éowyn decided to stay. She had great reason to, and no I didn't find this chapter scary at all, just very enjoyable.

Larner · 4 November 2008 · Chapter 2: Love never ends

Beautiful! And so right that Finduilas should be as glad to see her remain as to come with her.

Elflingimp · 4 November 2008 · Chapter 2: Love never ends

I liked that Linda, it was a very good story. Hugs The Imp

Lady_Roisin · 4 November 2008 · Chapter 2: Love never ends

This story was so powerful and amazing. I loved the concept and liked how you portrayed the spirit. It felt more believable than some glimmery see through thing floating about. I loved Finduilas' explination of Faramir's relationship with his father, and why it was the way it was. This was just amazing, and something new and unexpected from you. I could also appreciate that you didnt get too detailed about what ailed Eowyn, that part worried me a bit. But I was pleasantly surprised. You made a wise choice in not being graphic with that. Someties graphic works for medical things, but not others, just in my opinion. But even so, it still had every bit as much of an impact. This was really well written. I couldn't find any typos, but was mainly reading for the plot and characters, an all of that was well done and believable.

Larner · 2 November 2008 · Chapter 1: Roses have Thorns

I thought I saw some differences from the original. So, Elboron is born and now Eowyn is in distress? And Finduilas calls her son home to deal with it? Interesting! Now to see how the story evolves.

Estelcontar · 31 October 2008 · Chapter 1: Roses have Thorns

So Aragorn and Faramir managed to fall foul of a bush of roses? I'm sure Arwen will say I told you so. I really liked the first chapter of your extended version. I just hope you don't make it too scary.

harrowcat · 31 October 2008 · Chapter 1: Roses have Thorns

Those ladies really shouldn't let these two out of their sight should they! Dread is filling me for Eowyn!

Lâikwâlasse · 31 October 2008 · Chapter 1: Roses have Thorns

just another lovely glimpse of Faramir´s and Aragorn´s relationship. Roses have thorns - indeed! Faramir´s vision was chilling and I wondeer what happened to Eowyn... Thank you. Lai

Lady_Roisin · 30 October 2008 · Chapter 1: Roses have Thorns

It was nice to see a glimpse of Elboron's birth (I'm assuming it's Elboron, correct me if I'm wrong). How funny for Faramir to get caught in the rose bush! They certainly do hurt! I wonder what happened to Eowyn.