Reviews (234)

Agape4rivendell · 1 October 2020 · Chapter 44: Rekindling Hope

My goodness.... what a treat. I did not realize you were posting chapters. So glad I came to read Katzillas and decided to see what you’ve been up to. A glorious chapter. I noticed, in some comments, that someone said reading Lords of Gondor was like reading the master, himself. Love every word of this chapter. The Rohirrim, Boromir's men, Pippin and Gandalf... and Faramir. Exquisite. Blessings.

demeter d · 14 August 2020 · Chapter 57: Wind from the Sea

I am often glad that this site lets us do more than one review per chapter. Oops, the one with the loom is VAIRE, of course, not Varda! And, also, i am glad you are still traveling along with this story!

demeter d · 13 August 2020 · Chapter 57: Wind from the Sea

For an enjoyable take on the fresh south wind blowing up from the sea, go read Chapter 21, called "Breath of Arda" in Fiondil's "Tales From Varda's Loom." He suggests that Manwe and the Valar sent that wind to aid the cause of those on the side of Light. A hopeful story, just as this one is.

Bob Gorman · 10 April 2020 · Chapter 58: Horns from the North

Can't wait for this story to keep going. I can't wait to see the Boromir/Aragorn reunion!

Lindelea · 11 February 2020 · Chapter 2: Hands of a Healer

Have finally been able to carve out time for fanfic again, and so glad I saw this on the first page at SoA today! I am only at the beginning, but I have to say I love the way you've turned Boromir's familiar death scene into something much more hopeful. Looking forward to reading more.

Larner · 10 February 2020 · Chapter 58: Horns from the North

Indeed Hope is kindled, and hopefully Denethor will man up at this reassurance. So good to see this continued!

Larner · 10 February 2020 · Chapter 57: Wind from the Sea

The various threads of the story now knit together to begin the tale of the Battle of the Pelennor. Now, to see it played out with the addition of Boromir and his men.

mystarlight · 7 February 2020 · Chapter 1: Surrounded

Awesome beginning.

Tari · 6 February 2020 · Chapter 57: Wind from the Sea

I really need to start reading again. This story is way to good to miss.

bobbygniu · 5 February 2020 · Chapter 58: Horns from the North

So excited for another chapter. Thanks

shirebound · 3 February 2020 · Chapter 58: Horns from the North

I think Pippin transmits as much joy and hope to Gandalf as the wizard does to him. What a lovely conversation.

PSW · 4 November 2019 · Chapter 57: Wind from the Sea

Whew! I’ve just read this whole thing in two days, and it’s been an amazing treat! Thanks so much for all your hard work on this. I’m glad to see you’re still working on it, and I will look for the next update, whenever it may be. In the meantime, I’ll just say again that this is such an excellent tale ... Thanks for writing! :-)

shirebound · 31 August 2019 · Chapter 57: Wind from the Sea

Your description of Pippin's fright -- and incredible courage -- is excellent. Such an exciting story! It's wonderful to know that Theoden and Boromir are riding together for the defense of Gondor.

Wanderlust · 9 March 2019 · Chapter 56: Breaking Through Despair

I just started this story in the last couple of days and read it straight through. It is one of the best AUs that I've read. Your attention to detail, your dedication to keeping folks in character, and your thoughtful development of the plot all make this a wonderful story. And I'm not just saying this as a fan of Boromir who very much wishes that he could have seen the downfall of Sauron and the restoration of Gondor. Thanks for all the hard work you've put into this story; I hope you keep writing!

Larner · 19 January 2019 · Chapter 56: Breaking Through Despair

Oh, such a delight to see Durlin's hope inspiring even Denethor. As for Pippin, he is hope personified.

Anon · 19 January 2019 · Chapter 56: Breaking Through Despair

Great to see you pick this back up again! The moment between Denethor and Durlin was very touching. You've made me almost as desperate for Boromir's return as Denether himself, even though I know the rest of the story. Great work!

demeter d · 8 January 2019 · Chapter 55: 'Do Not Lose Heart'

My absolute favorite character of this whole story is your Durlin! If the original Denethor had a friend like him in his corner, perhaps he would have had a bit more hope of battling the darkness which claimed him in the book. The man quietly goes about trying to nurture Denethor, Faramir, Pippin, Imrahil, Gandalf, any one that he can! He reminds me of one bright spot in P.J.'s otherwise rather overdone (in my opinion!) Hobbit movies. As the Dwarves make camp near the spot where Bilbo will run afoul of the trolls, Gandalf comments that even though Saruman believes that only great power will defeat the Darkness, he himself has found that everyday good deeds of ordinary people also have power.

Larner · 7 January 2019 · Chapter 55: 'Do Not Lose Heart'

Aha! The return of the prodigal! So wonderful to find this! Love to see the changes to the original allowing Boromir to return to the city he loves so. (And LOVED The Elephant Thief!)

BM · 5 January 2019 · Chapter 55: 'Do Not Lose Heart'

I am absolutely thrilled to see a new chapter to this story! Your writing is so authentic with deep, rich characterization. The story remains very true to the spirit of the books, seemlessly weaving a very believable alternative history if Boromir had survived, and I am greatly enjoying it. I hope that the inspiration which led to this latest chapter continues!

Sylphrena33 · 15 April 2018 · Chapter 36: Fateful Folly

I'm really enjoying this. I love the buildup, and the growing tension. You can tell that the characters are feeling it, but the way that you've written it makes me feel it too. On a side note, I really like Durlin. He's a great OC, and I love his optimism and loyalty. I'm excited to see where this goes. :)

Agape4Gondor · 23 October 2017 · Chapter 43: Assailing Doubts

I am glad Faramir has someone to share his misgivings with and Durlin is the perfect person!

Agape4Gondor · 23 October 2017 · Chapter 42: Unexpected News

I do like Hurin. And Denthor's regard of the Warden of the Keys! Merry's time with Dernhelm is sweet -- but the joy of Aragorn! And of his companions -- that was worth waiting for!!!

Agape4Gondor · 23 October 2017 · Chapter 41: Memories of Boromir

Silly old me! I had clean forgotten about Frodo! Shame! Blessed chapter, the poor little Hobbit! And Sam, dear Sam! Never mind his upset at Boromir, he clearly accepts Frodo's forgiveness to the man. And Pippin! His forgiveness of Boromir - at last understanding. Such weary sadness for them all.

Agape4Gondor · 23 October 2017 · Chapter 40: Widening Rift

Again, Durlin proves his worth -- and his loyalty!

Agape4Gondor · 23 October 2017 · Chapter 39: A Chance Meeting

I love the reference to your prior tale! Loved seeing the reunion between Boromir and Surefoot!