A Star in Midwinter by Cairistiona

Reviews (140)

Write a review

Silivren Tinu · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 2: Mettarë Interrupted

I certainly wouldn't want to spend Mettarë hunting wolves! *joins Aragorn in grimacing* I hope Denlad will not drop dead from embarrassment and gratitude when he receives all those gifts. ;-) Aragorn's enthusiasm in preparing the gifts for Denlad was sweet. I hope those wolves won't ruin everything now. Loved it! :)

Author's reply

Thanks, Almut! I don't think I'd want to spend it hunting wolves, either. I'm not sure I'd want to spend *anything* hunting wolves! *shivers* I'm glad you liked a glimpse of Aragorn playing Santa. *g* Thanks for the review!

Mirach · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 2: Mettarë Interrupted

Ah, the presents! I was smiling with Aragorn in expectation of Denlad unwrapping them. It was really joyful to read this chapter, especially about the children and peppermint sticks. Fourty-eleven of them? ;) And Ivorwen But the end was sobering. No celebration... So it is not such a peaceful story as it seemed at the beginning. It's hard to miss the celebration, but of course, duty comes first... I'm curious what happens, and how the celebration wil go at last.

Author's reply

Thank you, Mirach! It was so fun to write Aragorn playing Santa, anticipating Denlad's happiness. And hmm, perhaps there was forty-eleven of those peppermints in his pockets! LOL And yes, sadly, as is often the case even in real life for soldiers, duty comes before celebrating. Thanks for the review!

Linda Hoyland · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 2: Mettarë Interrupted

I love the way you show Aragorn's kindness and care for his young protege. I think they usually sweetened drinks with honey in the olden days. I'm enjoying this gimpse of life in a Ranger village very much.

Author's reply

Thank you, Linda! I'm glad you're enjoying the tale. Honey or sugar, either one, poor Denlad doesn't have any to offer his Chieftain. Hope you enjoy the rest of the story--thanks for the review!

shirebound · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 2: Mettarë Interrupted

What wonderful gifts, and what a wonderful Chieftain. I especially appreciate this: "Aragorn felt strongly that the young man needed that formal assurance that here at last were the people with whom he belonged, with whom he could build the rest of his life." I wrote my 'Quarantined' stories around giving young Frodo that assurance, and I always enjoy that theme.

Author's reply

Thank you, shirebound! As I see Aragorn, I think creating a sense of belonging, of unity, would be very important to him, being one charged with holding together a scattered people, and then eventually rebuilding a war-torn nation. It's fun to explore that side him, isn't it? Thanks for the review!

Silivren Tinu · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Poor Denlad! You make me want to give him a big hug! *huggles embarrassed ranger-to-be* I love Aragorn - he's really great at taking care of his people, and he always seems to have the right words to say to make someone feel better (though at the moment, his words and friendliness probably confuse Denlad to no end). It's just heartwarming to think of what fate has in store for Denlad now, especially compared to what he's been through before. What a lonely and miserable life he's had. This chapter already makes me look forward to reading more! :)

Author's reply

Thank you, Almut! I'm certain Denlad appreciates the hugs... even though they're also likely confusing him as much as Aragorn's kindness! *g* Ah, embarrassed, confused, grieving, lonely... he's in a muddle, all right. I'm glad you enjoyed this first chapter--hopefully you'll enjoy the rest just as much! Thanks for the review!

Mirach · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Ah, a heartwarming story for Christmas from Cairistiona! Or, it promises to be, at least, because we already know Denlad and his close friendship with Aragorn later. And it is good to see them relax and enjoy the warmth of home for once. I was astounded how you managed to show the building of the fire like a dance with the rhythm of your words. I hope they show Denlad that he belongs there, too. Aragorn cares for every one of his people, as you show clearly here. Being a chieftain is more then leading them in fights, and that is often forgotten. And he has his own chicken! Aw, that made me feel so nostalgic... It reminds me on my great-grandmother when I was a small child. She had three chicken, and they were her pets, and mine too, together with her, and then after she died. They didn't have names, either, just Thin White, Thick White and Brown. This makes Aragorn and Denlad even closer to me, and brings the memory of my great-grandmother. Thank you!

Author's reply

Thank you, Mirach! Knowing how poetic your own writing is, I'm very flattered that you liked how I used a bit of rhythm in the bonfire scene... I'm not very handy with things like that so it means a lot to hear from someone who is that I stumbled upon a more poetic way of describing something! And how neat that the chickens brought back memories for you! Although I've never had chickens myself, I've heard stories of my grandmother having a chicken that lived in her house with her, grandly named Chanticleer, and I have aunts and uncles who have chickens and treat them as pets. So I suppose it's not such an uncommon thing! Thanks for the review!

Vilwarin · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Oh, what a wonderful beginning to a mettare story. I really had to cry all the way through. I think I can partly relate to Denlad; it is very hard to begin a new life among people that are so different from you. They are a tight community and know each other intimately - and you are the outsider. You know nothing about them or their customs and even look different. And for a shy man it is only natural to draw back into himself, which intensifies the feeling of not belonging. And then there is, of course, the feeling of being overwhelmed by the kindness of others that probably accept you more readily than you think. Again, wonderfully done and I'm looking forward to the next chapter.

Author's reply

Thank you, Vilwarin! Oh, you really have pegged what I'm trying to do with Denlad in this chapter and story. I think we've all been in that situation, perhaps not always as dramatically as Denlad but still finding ourselves as outsiders, wondering if the kindness is real, wondering how to possibly weave ourselves into a community that seems not to really *need* us. Those are the themes, to my mind, that Denlad as a character represents. As I told Radbooks in reply her review, I feel odd saying that I'm glad I made you cry, but I am incredibly encouraged that this chapter has brought readers to tears... it's so reassuring to know that I've created a character that people can relate to and connect with to that extent. Thank you for the review!

Ellynn · 18 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Aww, a story about Denlad. :) I'm so glad to read more about him. Poor guy, feeling so lonely and sad at the moment. Can I come in and comfort him a little' *laughing* I love the description of the village and cottage. P.S. The chieftain and chicken? What a picture! :)))

Author's reply

Thank you, Ellynn! Somehow I missed responding to this review... my apologies! And yes, chieftains and chickens, who knew! LOL I kind of liked that picture myself. And I'm certain that Denlad would LOVE for you to go in with some comforting hugs. :)

Elentarri · 17 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Hay!! Another story!! :) I love Denlad. And great writing as usual.

Author's reply

Thank you, Elentarri! I'm always so happy to hear that someone loves Denlad. The poor boy needs a lot of love. :) Thanks for the review and enjoy the tale!

Midnight Promise · 17 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Hello! WOOT WOOT! Another story! Favorite person! :3 And, better yet, its going into detail with Denlad! Aw...those people who were mean to him should be shot. . . ;p Aw, someone give that kid a hug! Haha, I think I said that in the last story too. :) Awesome job, loved it, and can't wait for more! If your in school, hope you're enjoying break. But if you're not. . .enjoy the season. :D Happy Holidays, MP

Author's reply

Thank you, MP... I'm with you in thinking the bullies and the meanies that were so cruel to Denlad need to be drawn and quartered. Of course, I'm biased, since Denlad is "my" child, so it's very good to hear that a reader feels that same sort of teeth-grinding outrage. Denlad does need hugs... lots of them... so feel free. :) My student days are looooong behind me (thank heavens) but I'm enjoying the holidays as always. You have a wonderful Christmas and New Year as well! Thanks again for the review!

Minerva Organa · 17 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

I can't get over the pure squee that ensued upon reading this. I do believe Denlad is one of my favorite OC's ever. You capture him so beautifully...I can't wait for more of this!

Author's reply

Oh, so that was that high-pitched sound I heard in the east! *g* Thank you, Minerva--I'm so glad you enjoyed this first chapter, and of course it makes *me* squee knowing that Denlad's becoming such a favorite of yours. Thanks for the review and enjoy the rest of the story!

Radbooks · 17 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Oh, this is very, very good... you made me tear up, which I don't do too often. :) I'm looking forward to the next chapter!

Author's reply

Thank you, Radbooks! It sounds rather cold to say I'm glad I made you cry but, well, the writer in me is very glad to know that I touched your emotions so. Thank you for the review!

Estelcontar · 17 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

What a lovely start for your Yule fiction. I just loved to see the Dúnedain preparing their Mettarë bonfire through Denlad's eyes, and the view of Halbarad was very revealing. This was a very poetic glimpse on their daily lives, when they were not fighting orcs, and other evil things, but happy enjoying themselves. The way Denlad feels sounds very convincing too. It would be difficult at the start for a solitary and shy youngster like he had always been to fit in and feel at home in such a thightly knit community as the Dúnedain were bound to be. As usual, I loved how you presented Aragorn. His kindness, perceptiveness, considerateness and concern for others ring really, really true. So also do you Dírhael and Ivorwen. I really enjoyed the bit about the chickens, and the name you came up with for them. A wonderful beginning indeed.

Author's reply

Thank you, Estelcontar! I'm so glad you enjoyed this first chapter. I love exploring the "home life" of the Dunedain, how they might live and relate to one another and help each other when they are fortunate enough to live closely like those in this settlement do. I'm very glad Denlad is convincing... I do want him to be fully developed as a character, as much as the canon characters. Thanks for the review!

shirebound · 17 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

Reading this, I was swept right into that young man's meager home and longing heart and mixed emotions. What beautiful writing. It's wonderful to learn of Denlad's youth, and how he grew to know his people and heritage... and Chieftain.

Author's reply

Thank you, Shirebound! I'm so glad you liked this first chapter. Denlad does have a longing heart... he's never known a father or close family ties aside from what love his mother spared him. So this is an entirely new world for him. Thank you for the lovely review!

Raksha The Demon · 17 December 2009 · Chapter 1: On the Outside Looking In

The culture of the Northern Dunedain is beautifully depicted here - the hardship, pride, and compassion even to a lonely and fatherless boy. I wonder if Denlad is going to think that Aragorn is his father... And, as always, good characterization of Aragorn! Looking forward to more.

Author's reply

Thank you, Raksha! I'm so glad you enjoyed the depiction of Dunedain life I'm trying to show here. I think the Dunedain were definitely a special folk, not entirely perfect but a people who nonetheless strive to be kind and compassionate and true to the nobility of their heritage, even to extending a welcoming hand to an orphan (even if that orphan is nearly grown to manhood). As for Denlad thinking Aragorn his father... hmm, probably not in any literal sense. But a father figure... yes, definitely. Thank you for the review--I hope you continue to enjoy the story!