Captive in Cirith Ungol by Lily Dragonquill

Reviews (3)

Write a review

Queen Galadriel · 25 October 2005 · Chapter 1: Captive in Cirith Ungol

Excellent story, Lily! And your first English fanfic? Cool! I've read other stories on various sites that try to tell Frodo's side, but almost all of them are dark and without hope. I like how you ended with that quote from the book, in my opinion the sweetest, most touching part of the entire LOTR. I look forward to reading more of your work! Namarie, and God bless, Galadriel

Author's reply

Wow, I never thought anybody would still look at these old snippets. Thank you so much for having a look at it. I needed some hope in the story, after all there is still some hope left in the book as well, so why make it darker than this time is for Frodo anyhow?

Hobbit Lass21 · 29 April 2005 · Chapter 1: Captive in Cirith Ungol

Never liked those Orcs. Never. So glad Sam slaughtered them.....*gleefully imagines throttling a couple dozen Orcs* So real too. I could feel myself flincing every time they...*shivers* Bravo.

Author's reply

Wow, thank you! This was my first English story and I thought never would ever go reading it. I'm glad you "enjoyed" it anyhow :)

trishette · 15 September 2003 · Chapter 1: Captive in Cirith Ungol

Wow.. I could actually see the Cirith Unglol scene as if it were before me, reading this!