To Tell a Tale by Lindelea

Reviews (80)

Write a review

pebbles66 · 4 October 2005 · Chapter 2: Silent Knight, by Shirebound

Oh, how sweet! Pippin just wanted to make his king proud, and of course, Aragorn is extremely proud of him already. Lovely.

Author's reply

From Shirebound: I'm so happy you enjoyed this! It was fun to write.

Andrea · 4 October 2005 · Chapter 2: Silent Knight, by Shirebound

A wonderful story so far! Well, the plot to distract Frodo from his own brooding worked perfectly! It was a plot, wasn't it? And I've never thought of Aragorn feeling like a child among all those elves, who never get ill - that's really unfair ;-) Now I'm waiting for Frodo's attempt to make Pippin stay in bed. At the moment, he's too weak to get up, but knowing hobbits and especially Pippin, that might not last for long.

Author's reply

From Shirebound: Thanks, Andrea! It's wonderful to have been a part of Lindelea's story challenge. I really enjoy writing scenes between Pippin and his "teachers" -- such as Aragorn.

Bodkin · 4 October 2005 · Chapter 2: Silent Knight, by Shirebound

I'm glad to see that worrying about Pippin has been good for Frodo. He is the sort of hobbit who doesn't like being the centre of attention - but does like to look after his cousins. And Aragorn would recognise the problems of being seen as a kid when you are an adult after having spent his youth in the care of elves. I love the suggestion that once you find your heart, it stops mattering - and that the 2700ish Arwen sees him as he is. Very touching. Lovely story.

Author's reply

From Shirebound: Thank you so much. I enjoyed bringing in Aragorn to have a conversation with Pippin. Our young Took has been able to learn so much from everyone he's met on the Quest, and I can imagine he would feel a mixture of awe for his King and familiarity with 'Strider'.

Bodkin · 4 October 2005 · Chapter 1: Come Early, Come Late

I had forgotten about this! Poor Pippin. I expect he would, if pushed, prefer anything to going without food. And what a day to get ill! He's missed all the fun of the coronation. The food. The ale. The conviviality. I'm glad Beregond went out to look for him.

harrowcat · 4 October 2005 · Chapter 1: Come Early, Come Late

What a great start to a promising story but you can't leave us hanging in mid-air with such a poorly Pippin on our hands - I'm already screaming for Aragorn! Are you vieing to see who could leave the best cliffie? evil authors, evil! Now I can't decide whether to go over to LJ and look for this or endure the suspense!

Author's reply

Well, you get your wish. Aragorn is about to appear, courtesy of Shirebound. Thanks for commenting!