Tales of Life by Aelaer

Reviews (382)

Write a review

Fimbrethil · 29 May 2025 · Chapter 75: Morning: Matter of the Morn (A. + Legolas + Gimli + Eldarion + others)

A great story! Is it continued? Is there more birthday celebration? Do Legolas and Gimli manage to return the mumak? Oh, and what does Arwen think about Eldarion riding the mumak?

Fimbrethil · 29 May 2025 · Chapter 66: Wildlife: The Gift (A. + Eldarion + OC)

In reply to Estelcontar: giving the mumak to Elladan and Elrohir would probably be worse than keeping it. Just think of all the mischief E. & E. could do with the mumak! Though Aragorn would have to keep it, and probably shortly Eldarion will be not only able to think like his uncles, but act like them, too!

Fimbrethil · 29 May 2025 · Chapter 47: Storm: It Can't Get Any Worse (A. only)

Actually, I guess it was only on the edge of my mind, was the part when Théoden said “Let them come.” I don’t remember if that was before or after “So it begins.”

Fimbrethil · 29 May 2025 · Chapter 47: Storm: It Can't Get Any Worse (A. only)

Reminds me of Théoden at Helm’s Deep. “So it begins.” First the orcs and co. arrive, then it starts to rain, and then, after all the talk about The Hornburg not falling yet, etc., the walls are blown up—and so forth.

Fimbrethil · 29 May 2025 · Chapter 42: Peace: The Secret Garden (A. + Arwen + Faramir)

That last review was me. Faramir eventually returning and working in the garden would be very good indeed. And hope he brings at least Éowyn, if not their children…

Fimbrethel · 29 May 2025 · Chapter 71: Healing: The King's Hands (A. + Faramir)

He smiled slightly. "I am not king yet, Faramir." "But you will be!" he said. "Gondor has no need for me now." "You underestimate your value, son of Denethor," said Aragorn. "She has need of you. Her people have need of you. I have need you." He held out his hand. "Come, Faramir. There are many who await your return." …. reminds me of “Gondor has no king. Gondor needs no king.” But “I need you. Your father needs you. Gondor needs you.” to Faramir. Faramir and Boromir are complete opposites in this: Boromir thinks they need no king; Faramir, on the RotK, thinks they need no Steward. Also nice coming right after the previous where Estel chooses Athelas.

Fimbrethel · 29 May 2025 · Chapter 70: Green: Healing Herbs (A. + Elrond)

Elrond's eyes lit up as he recognized the leaves. "An interesting choice, Estel. Now this is athelas, also known as kingsfoil and asëa aranion, and it has a long history behind it…" Heehee, Estel would pick that. Do you think Elrond used some to heal Frodo?

Fimbrethel · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 62: Celebration: Preparation (A.+ Arwen + Faramir + Legolas)

Hmmmhmmm They are hilarious. Good to know the master-of-ceremonies would work with Elves.

Fimbrethil · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 58: Prank: Diplomatic Tensions (A. + Éomer + Arwen + Lothíriel)

heehee! But somehow Elfwine is three years older than Eldarion?

Fimbrethil · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 49: Custom: From the North (A. + Imrahil)

Heehee. Brotherly obligations with the sister who is not Finduilas? Or does he mean to keep Finduilas’s actions with Denethor in propriety?

Anonymous · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 42: Peace: The Secret Garden (A. + Arwen + Faramir)

Awwww…the similarities between Faramir and his parents and Colin and his parents.. Both fathers trying to hide their love, pretending they don’t love their sons, each deeply in love with their wives, both morn her after her death and in this case, lock her garden.., For both an unrelated girl discovers it and decides to tend it.

Fimbrethil · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 41: Road: The Road Home (A. + Elrond)

Awww…in a son/father of the beloved sort of way of course. And he will wait for the twins!

Fimbrethil · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 34: Enemy: The Palantír (A. + Sauron)

Aragorn stabbing the Eye through reminded me of him stabbing the Mouth through. Oh Wait, he cut of the head. Éowyn stabbed the Witchking’s mouth/head through, and beheaded the fell beast. Well, that is what it reminded me of, I could almost see it in my head.

Fimbrethel · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 29: Guest: A Wife's Wrath (A. + OC)

Heehee…it’s a good thing the inn keeper doesn’t know Strider translates to Telecontar in Sindarin.

Fimbrethel · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 28: Childproof: Terrible Twos (A + Arwen + Eldarion + OCs)

Awwww. I wonder how Eldarion and Eleniel will be when they grow up? Or rather, different stories throughout the years. Like, what will they do when they are 8? 15? 21? And actually, yes, seeing them be twins when they are older than that… This is the first of the line of twins where one of them is a girl. Also, wouldn’t Faramir have young children of his own? Might he not not want to go to the meeting?

Fimrethel · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 25: Hunger: A Quick Bite (A. + OC)

Awww…and then he tells this episode to Faramir, and Faramir explains his adventures to the kitchen or elsewhere throught the citadel in his younger days.

Fimbrethil · 28 May 2025 · Chapter 1: Lost: The Quest (A. + Imrahil + OC)

The first half at least of this is adorable!

Janvpals · 27 May 2022 · Chapter 41: Road: The Road Home (A. + Elrond)

this left me teary-eyed. so beautifully written. so so so beautiful.

Estelcontar · 29 June 2011 · Chapter 75: Morning: Matter of the Morn (A. + Legolas + Gimli + Eldarion + others)

A most delicious drabble. It brought a smile to my face.

Linda Hoyland · 25 June 2011 · Chapter 75: Morning: Matter of the Morn (A. + Legolas + Gimli + Eldarion + others)

It cannot be easy for Kings to know what to do with some of the gifts they receive! Delightful!

Cairistiona · 23 June 2011 · Chapter 75: Morning: Matter of the Morn (A. + Legolas + Gimli + Eldarion + others)

Heh! Eldarion throws tantrums, I love it! Everyone always writes him so perfectly behaved but I like this take on him... it feels very normal and natural. And I like the way Aragorn is handling it, thanks, evidently to Faramir's wise counsel. And I like your new name!

Author's reply

Hey Cair (yes, your new nickname!), As you know, I have a sister who is 6 and will be 7 in few months. She is the most well-behaved child I have ever seen... and even she has tantrums from time to time. I figure that Eldarion and his siblings, especially when they were younger, would have the same issues. :) Even the most well-behaved children have tantrums! And thanks! :D

Estelcontar · 22 June 2011 · Chapter 74: Wish: A New Age (A. + Arwen)

A very touching, and wistful vignette. I'm glad that though sad, they were able to comfort each other in the end.

Estelcontar · 22 June 2011 · Chapter 73: Garden: New Growth (A. + Arwen)

Lovely vignette. I think very fitting that Arwen should restore to full glory Finduilas' garden.

shirebound · 19 June 2011 · Chapter 74: Wish: A New Age (A. + Arwen)

That's a lovely and very realistic scene.

Cairistiona · 17 June 2011 · Chapter 73: Garden: New Growth (A. + Arwen)

Very sweet.... I love thinking about all the gardening and replanting of trees that must have taken place after the War.