Larner
· 1 December 2007
· Chapter 2: Out on a Limb
I wonder if, when she knitted Tulip, Eglantine realized she was providing her son with a companion conscience? Wonderful, particularly as she takes the piglet's share of the cookies!
Author's reply
Heh, heh - I think Pip really needs that extra conscience to help keep his mischievous self out of so much trouble! Thanks so much for commenting!
Edlyn
· 30 November 2007
· Chapter 2: Out on a Limb
Cathleen, I have been enjoying your Pip & Tulip fics so much and this one was wonderful! You really have developed Tulip's voice so well in this. And of course, Pippin's responses to her (sometimes rather emphatic) nudging are perfect. I can just imagine what's going ot happen when they get home . Great job!
Author's reply
Thank you so much for your generous comments, they are much appreciated! I'm so glad to hear you like Tulip, she is still a work in progress.
Neilia
· 30 November 2007
· Chapter 2: Out on a Limb
Have you ever noticed how toddlers and slightly older younglings always tell on themselves one way or another? As a mother, I have had many times when I could barely suppress laughter when one of my kiddos did so. Tulip is a great way to show the magic of whimsy. Hope to hear more from her.
Author's reply
Absolutely, and I used that very idea as a model for this, too! I'm so pleased to hear you like Tulip - thank you!
shirebound
· 29 November 2007
· Chapter 2: Out on a Limb
Pippin's imagination is just delightful. Tulip is such a wonderful guardian and friend.
Author's reply
Awww, thanks Shirebound! I'm very pleased you like Tulip. Yes, she is the imaginative voice of Pip's conscience. Heaven knows the lad needs all the help he can get in staying out of trouble!
Pearl Took
· 28 November 2007
· Chapter 1: Lily Took
Aw! All warm and snuggly :-) I do so love Tulip! The opening scene was wonderfully done :-)
Author's reply
Thank you so much Pearl! I'm having great fun writing Tulip - she's truly taken on a life of her own.
Grey Wonderer
· 25 November 2007
· Chapter 1: Lily Took
That was sweet.
Author's reply
Why, thank you! Glad you liked it!
Larner
· 25 November 2007
· Chapter 1: Lily Took
Ahh, so cute! Lovely!
Haven't had time to respond to the challenge myself--am working on my Yule fic--and all the others that are throwing themselves at me.
Help! I'm under siege by plot bunnies and nuzguls!
Author's reply
Thank you! Tulip is the one who's had *me* under plot bunny siege lately!
Glad you liked it.
Neilia
· 25 November 2007
· Chapter 1: Lily Took
OMG! If this isn't adorable! Hugs to you for such a cute Pippin! Talking toys, yeah! Neilia
Author's reply
Thank you very much - glad to hear you enjoyed it!
Andrea
· 25 November 2007
· Chapter 1: Lily Took
Tulip’s knitted heart softened at the sight and her eyes shone.
Awww! I've never heard of Tulip before. But I'm sure there are more stories to discover about Pippin and his knitted friend, aren't there?
I also loved the name "Snowflake", very appropriate - and nice. I don't care what Merry thinks about it ;-)
Thank you for this sweet little story!
Author's reply
Thanks so much for your kind comments, I'm very pleased to hear you enjoyed it! Tulip first appeared in my story "If You Could See What I Hear" which is still a WIP. You can locate it here on SOA - thank you for asking!
Cathleen
Lily
· 25 November 2007
· Chapter 1: Lily Took
That's a very cute story.
Author's reply
Thank you Lily! Glad you think so!
shirebound
· 24 November 2007
· Chapter 1: Lily Took
This is totally *beyond* sweet, adorable, and darling! I just can't get enough of Piglet and her hobbit lad.
Author's reply
Sirebound, thank you so much! It's *very* gratifying to hear you enjoy Tulip with Pippin. The knitted piglet has become more than I expected her to be in the beginning, and she is great fun to write!
Thanks again for reading!