Stars May Collide by Rose Gamgee
Elia · 12 June 2006 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
Hey, I've read parts of your story on other fanfiction sites (Parma Eruseen and...I can't remember the other one), and always thought of it as my favorite Pippin and Diamond fanfic. I seem to remember there being more... I could easily be wrong and be confusing it with something else, but that thought persists. At any rate, fabulous story. You have a gift!
EstellaB · 2 May 2006 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
*gasps* Is this finished? Is it not? It's wonderful at any rate... Thankyou!
Tinwetari · 11 January 2005 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
I can honestly say that I am in love with this story. You've managed to flesh out the character of Diamond completely, and made her believable. Please continue. I must read more! :)
Samwisegirl12, who is too lazy to login · 15 August 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
Hey RG! Don't mean to bug you, I'm just requesting an update, and I'm here to cheer and encourage you! *pulls out pom poms* Gimmie an "R"! Gimmie an "O"! Gimmie an "S"! Gimmie an "E"! Gimmie a G-A-M-G-double-E! What's that spell? Rose Gamgee!!! (*pleads for update, grovels*) yayayay! Pippin and Diamond FOREVER!!! ~ swg ~
Bluegrass Elf · 23 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
How beautiful!
Valerie · 18 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
*squeals* That was so good! I've been waiting forever for this chapter, and it's finally come, and it's SOOOO GOOOOD!!! I loved all of the characterizations, as usual. I can't WAIT to see what their parents are going to say!
powerwriter · 16 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
Finally, a new chapter! Ooo...it never crossed my mind that they'd go to Sam and want him to marry them! How wonderful. It's good to see Pip and Di married, but how are things going to go now that they are?! Things won't be so easy for them...
Le Rouret · 15 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
Marriage proposals appear to be in the air for me . . . in my WIP I just had Legolas propose to Eowyn. Go fig. Once again, a great chapter to a great story! I'm pleased you had Sam and Merry not only realize what Pippin and Diamond were doing was rash and impulsive, but that you let them slip in their compassion and tenderness at the same time. As always, they were angry at Pip's actions, not Pip himself. Lovely! Can't wait to see what Uncle Paladin thinks of this! LR
Hai Took · 15 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
Their married!? Yay! Very sensible of Rose, perhaps she is a romantic but she was able to see what needed to be done to win over the other two into helping Pippin and Diamond get married! Now they only have to face the wrath of their parents! Looking forward to more!
Grey Wonderer · 15 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
I dearly loved this chapter. Thank goodness for Rose or those two practical hobbits might have made a mess of things. I can't wait for more.
darksun · 14 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
You are a brilliant beyond brilliant writer, you know that don't you? <3 This is so incredible. I never knew how much depth you could pull into a story with Diamond and Pippin, but you succeeded. I love this. So sweet my teeth ache. I'm so happy for them. I think Merry acted just the way he should have acted. And poor Pippin... bringing up the Palantír, even! Gah. Diamond is just so sweet, so gentle. So much unconditional love. And go Rosie! I love how you portray all the characters. Wonderful job, love.
Samwisegirl12, who is too lazy to login · 14 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
yay!! *bounces up and down* hoorah! you've updated. That bit about the look Diamond gave Pippin made me smile, Rose. sooo cute. Yes, I love Pip and Di, but I kinda was thinking that Sam was right.. I just hate to see Sam breaking the law cuz I luv him soo... oh, well.. They're married at last! Now we can prepare for some more.. fluffy hobbit cuteness! But... Pip and Di's parents and family still have to be told *duhn duhn duhn duhn!* Can't wait for the next update. THANKIE THANKIE THANKIE for this chappie! ~ swg ~
Estella Brandybuck · 14 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
Brilliant! I love it! Understandable about life hassels. I have a 2 year old daughter. Take your time. We will all be here waiting to eagerly read the next chapter. Good luck!
Annis · 14 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
WOW. simply wow. I never thought to read this story before, but on a whim, I decided to give it a try - I'm glad I did! This is absolutly wonderful! Well done!
songspinner · 14 July 2004 · Chapter 20: Under the Hill, Under the Stars
Oh, my...sniffle. That was wonderful. I just love Merry here - typical. First get irritated with Pip and then being absolutely unable to deny him much of anything. And trust him to appreciate Diamond for her strength and ability to take care of Pippin. That was perfect. Rosie's anger with Merry and Sam was good, too. Heh...I wouldn't want to cross her, either. Can't wait for the next part!
Valerie · 11 July 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
*sniffle* I come to this site everyday in hopes of seeing "Stars May Collide" on the recent updates list, or at least for chapter 20. It has been such a very long time since you're last update. Please, if it is at all possible, update soon! I really want to know what happens with Pippin and Diamond (well, obviously they get married, but you know what I mean...).
Bluegrass Elf · 11 July 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
Write more soon!
powerwriter · 11 July 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
FINALLY! That was one of the best chapters of the whole story! No, probably *the* best. Where will Pippin and Diamond go too? Will she decide to go back to her family? Ooo...so emotional. Please post the next chapter soon :)
Le Rouret · 28 June 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
Ooooh, they're gonna get in trouuubblllee . . . . Though, now I think of it, it would've been a lot more convenient (and cheaper) to have eloped, and foregone the whole bridesmaid gowns/flowers/wedding reception crapola. Post quickly! I wanna find out what happens! Le Rouret
Estella Brandybuck · 23 June 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
*Gasp and throws a body pillow under Diamond's covers* there...mayhap that will keep some suspicion off....*chews lip*....hmmm...*just had to help in some way* Wonderful chapter! Good to see that Diamond did not take her fathers words to heart too badly....Good to know it did not discourage her. And wonderful to know that Pippin is willing to take such a risk. Way to go Pip!
evila_elf · 6 June 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
Noooooooo!!! I kept hoping that there would be no end to the chapters, but have finally found one :( I Do hope you write more of this lovely story. Dang, I normally don't read this type of fic. I only started cause it was listed on Marigold's site and it had Pippin in it...a couple paragraphs into it and I was hooked. I even had to wipe at my eyes to continue to read the print several times!! And again when there was no 'next chapter' link! :( Wow! Really looking forward to the next chapter!!!!
Cm · 2 June 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
Pippin and Diamond are running away together! --That's not going to turn out too well. Poor Pip and Diamond, all they want is to be with each other...well, great job, and keep up the good work!
Hai Took · 25 May 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
Yay! They were finally discovered so now everything can be out in the open! I can't wait for them to get to marry although I'm sure that is going to cause more problems with both of their families! Looking forward to more!
Valerie · 24 May 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
AAAAAAAAUUUUUUUUGGGGGGGHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!! *collapses into a weepy mess of tears* That was...I cannot put into words what I thought of that chapter. You certainly weren't just whistlin' Dixie when you said that this would be an important chapter!! That was absolutely superb. Superb, I tells ya! I almost cried when Diamond left. I was embarrased and scared when her father found out. Poor Opal! Good sweet Opal! What a wonderful sister. And Fildigrim! At first I was thinking, "Oh what a jerk!" But then I realized that he really just loves his sister and doesn't want her to get hurt. Gah, I can't wait 'til Merry and Estella meet Diamond :P. I can't WAIT til the next chapter!!!!!!!!
Samwisegirl12 · 24 May 2004 · Chapter 19: Take Courage, Lover
Yay! an update! I always look forward to reading another chapter of your fics. woah... elopeing..I must say, that's a very Pippin-like idea! This was one of your best chapters yet, Rose Gamgee! Please don't leave us hanging. Oh, and congrats to the wonderful beta reader on her engagement! (I hope it won't slow the updates! lol, j/k) ~ swg ~