Forging Hope by Ellie

Reviews (89)

Write a review

Fiondil · 5 April 2014 · Chapter 5: Chapter 5

Belegon is such a jerk. Good thing the other Men in the village stood up to him. Had to laugh over the whole conversation at the cabin. Poor Laurehér and then when he finally understood what they were implying! LOL! Can it get any more embarrassing then that? And then the dream... poor guy, thinking that the hated brother is Olwion, whom he thought he loved. He is one really mixed-up ellon, unable to understand what he's dreaming and coming to so many wrong conclusions because he has so little information to go on. You really want to give him a big hug.

Author's reply

He really is a jerk, but he is not alone in his opinions, unfortunately. The conversation in the cabin was uncomfortable for him at best once he realized what was going on. I, too, pity him for his dreams and his wrong conclusions. He really is trying, but it is going rather badly, isn't it? Faroniel is the only one in a position to give the big guy a hug though :-( Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I do appreciate it very much!

Fantasia · 3 April 2014 · Chapter 6: Chapter 6

For some reason, I never read this story, luckily, I decided to read it today. It is very beautiful and sad. Laurehér will have the surprise of his life when he really knows who he is. That he is learning the story of his sons from the mortals' perspective is very significant. I don't think that any Elf can really understand Findataro's importance for humans. And I can help to feel sad about those mortals, even Belegon, which it doesn't excuse him for his actions. Now, Faroniel, it such a tragic character, she is heading to another heartache. Because I don't think that she can avoid to fall in love with her golden lord.

Author's reply

Welcome aboard, Fantasia! I'm very glad you decided to read this story :-) I can say that Laurehér is in for many surprises. He is in a rather unique position for learning about his sons, but he has no idea they are his sons and they are the only elves he really gets to learn about by name from the mortals. Faroniel certainly is heading for something as well. Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!

Twoflower2 · 26 March 2014 · Chapter 5: Chapter 5

I know this is petty, but I hope that Belegon will be very, very afraid when he realizes whom exactly he gave such a terrible beating. It's nice to see that other villagers are more accepting of Arafinwe.

Author's reply

Belegon might well be very very afraid when he realizes to whom he gave such a terrible beating, but first our poor elf must realize for himself who he is. So far, he only has a name for himself but no real sense of identity beyond that. Arafinwe is lucky to have some of the villagers on his side. We'll see how that goes for him as well soon enough. Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!

Fiondil · 20 March 2014 · Chapter 4: Chapter 4

The first dream he has and the erroneous conclusions he draws from it are funny but sad at the same time because we know the truth even if he doesn't. The second dream, though, was more telling, though I doubt he understood it any better than the first. Faroniel was wise to imply to the villagers that he was mind-damaged. That should keep him safe for now. Working at the smithy should help as well, allowing him to become familiar with the villagers and they with him.

Author's reply

It would feel pretty useless to be a sailor in a forest... Neither dream was very helpful to him if he even fully realizes they were memories and not just dreams. Faroniel does have his best interests at heart, but he has a hard time seeing this. There really is a lot that he does not know. Working in the village will provide him with an education whether he wants it to or not. Thank you so very much for taking the time to read and review. I appreciate it very much!

Twoflower2 · 19 March 2014 · Chapter 4: Chapter 4

Hi Ellie. I peeked into your page to check if you've posted anything new (loved "Warriors Proud") and here it is! Very, very interesting. A silver-haired beauty saving a warrior does ring a bell, though :) Not that I have anything against this. Otherwise, a refreshingly unusual premise, at least for me. I do wonder about some things. Why is Faroniel silver-haired? I thought it was Teleri hair color, which no human should have. Why does she - a hunter in a primitive settlement - know Quenya, the Latin of that world? And reading about all those soothing embraces, I suspect that soon Arafinwe will have to break her heart explaining her about LACE. I look forward to Arafinwe regaining his memory. It will probably happen when he is ready to come to terms with who he is and what happened to his family and his people. Cheers - Two2

Author's reply

I'm glad you loved "Warriors Proud". I hope you enjoy this story :-) "Warriors Proud" had silver-haired people because they were Galadhrim and since Tolkien never told us what the Galadhrim looked like, I went with Peter Jackson's silver-haired take on them. In "Forging Hope", Faroniel having silver hair is significant. Faroniel is of the folk of Hador Goldenhead among other clans of the edain. There are varying shades of blonde so it stands to reason that at some point platinum or silver blondes would be produced among the clan of Hador. As for the Teleri being silver-haired, Olwe's line is described as having the rare combination of silver hair and blue eyes, but that bloodline (which includes his brothers Elwe and Elmo), is the only group of Teleri described by Tolkien as having silver hair and blue eyes. Arafinwe's wife is the daughter of Olwe. As for Faroniel knowing Quenya and being able to read it... She explains this, I think in chapter 1, talking about how she is of the kin of Andreth who was attested to be a friend of Finrod and his brohter Aicanairo and was beloved of Aicanairo. It stands to reason that knowledge of that elf language which was the native language of Andreth's lover would have been passed down through the generations. You can read what Tolkien had to say about Andreth in "Athrabeth Finrod ah Andreth" in the HoME book Morgoth's Ring. As for Faroniel being all touchy feely on Arafinwe, some people are just like that and some people are lonely mortals with cute elves trapped in their lives and since they appear to be rather fond of the story of Andreth and Aicanairo... well, you can draw your own conclusions from that. Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!

Larner · 19 March 2014 · Chapter 4: Chapter 4

It certainly makes sense that he should learn to sail and to fish, as well as that he should have been apprenticed to Aule in his turn. These are good memories to have returned to him first. Now, to see how the recovery continues. Love the interactions with the smith and the others in the forge. And I do suspect that Faroniel is exaggerating the danger he faces from the villagers a bit so as to keep him bound to her at least for now.

Author's reply

Well, the sailing memory was unhelpful to him, but knowing he was apprenticed to Aule was a good thing to recall. As for the villagers at the forge, at least he has been accepted and has a job now. We'll find out soon enough how much Faroniel is exaggerating about the danger he faces. Thank you so very much reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!

Fiondil · 14 March 2014 · Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Faroniel was right to shoot an arrow at him. He had been thoughtless in his leaving as he did. At least she forgave him and accepted him back. Now he really believes he is alone and that has to be so frightening for him. Hopefully Faroniel will ease is loneliness a little and he will find some meaning in his life now even with everything he's lost, especially since he can't really remember what it was he's lost.

Author's reply

Arafinwe just had to get some answers and didn't like what he found out. He has to be terrified as he gropes his way through life right now. It is a good thing that Faroniel is forgiving and patient with him. Let's hope she can continue to be so and doesn't try to put another arrow in him. He isn't making very good choices lately, is he? Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!

Larner · 12 March 2014 · Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Not the meeting he'd envisioned, if he even had a meeting in his imagination thought out. But he's wrong to despair before he knows all of the facts.

Author's reply

No, it was not the meeting he was expecting, poor guy. I think he does not fully understand just how, for lack of a better word, "damaged" he is from all that he has endured physically and emotionally as well. At least he is in an environemnt where he can get some support so maybe he can try to sort himself out. Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!

Fiondil · 10 March 2014 · Chapter 2: Chapter 2

He's starting all over again and that can't be easy. He's lucky Faroniel was willing to take him in and teach him. In many ways he's almost like a child needing help. Not telling her he was leaving, though, isn't a good thing, but most males of any species don't think about things like that. *grin*

Author's reply

It has got to be extremely difficult to be in his position and he did luck out in finding Faroniel or really being found by her. He seems to be in the mindset of a caged animal, so it is no wonder he didn't reason through the consequences of his actions. I'm not saying males tend to behave like caged animals, though it kind of sounds like I am, but then again... LOL Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I do appreciate it very much!

Larner · 9 March 2014 · Chapter 2: Chapter 2

He certainly has reason to seek out his own people, and I can understand his fears of the lady's motivations. It is time to be back to his own responsibilities. I grieve for the brother-in-law's attitude. Love the name she gives him, which is definitely apropos. But wouldn't she know Finderato as Finrod instead? That, I understand, was the name he was known as within Middle Earth by its own citizens.

Author's reply

I have to imagine that there were some pretty negaitve feelings among those who were left behind when other able-bodied men were called to go to the war to fight beside the Elves. I had not explored this concept in Middle-Earth wars until this story. I've been surprised by how strongly some of these characters feel about this. As for Finrod versus Findarato, Arafinwe speaks only Quenya at the beginning of this chapter and is conversing with Faroniel in that language about a book written in that language. Once he learns Sindarin he is more apt to use Sindarin names for folk as is she. I think she was hoping that, considering he was from Valinor, using the names folk would have had in Valinor would have helped jog his memory. As we discovered, it really did not help at all. We'll see soon how it goes for Arafinwe trying to seek out his own kind once again. Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!

galathil · 5 March 2014 · Chapter 2: Chapter 2

Hi Ellie another beautiful chapter.Full of hope despite the loss. Hope our they get together very soon.They need one another, even if they don't relies it at the moment. Can't wait for the next chapter. Hope you are staying warm and feeling well. LOL Galathil

Author's reply

It is good to hear from you again :-) I'm glad you are enjoying the story so far. There is hope despite the loss, but there are too many unanswered questions for Arafinwe to be at peace right now. Perhaps his search for the army will turn up something for him. We are staying warm, but I am ready for winter to give up and go away. The flu season is landing the occasional blow on our family. Just got the latest victim healed and back to school. I hope the others don't get any ideas... Thank you for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!

Rhyselle · 2 March 2014 · Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Oh, more please? *looks pleadingly at author* While I have been blessed to have never seen combat, my conversations with elderly WWII veterans has given me some little knowledge of the mental scars that battle leaves behind even when a soldier is not physically wounded. Your description of what Arafinwe is feeling matches up with what I've been told about the aftermath of losing one's men, one's comrades, one's friends. I feel so very sorry for Arafinwe, but in a way he's been hit with "be careful what you wish for", and while the amnesia might temporarily take away the pain of his grief for his sons, when he finally does come back to himself, it will be there again. One can only hope that in the events to follow the end of the chapter (I do hope there will be more!) he will learn what he needs to learn to be able to cope with his losses and grief in a more constructive manner than running off into the middle of nowhere and into life-threatening danger. You write wonderful stories, Ellie. I'm glad to see another from your pen. :-)

Author's reply

I have never seen comabt myself, nor do I wish to, but I have had friends who were in the military. I tried to imagine what an ellon with a conscience and compassion would have endured, dealing with all that Arafinwe has endured in his life. It had to get to him some days. You will see how he ends up coping with everything in the coming chapters. I am delighted that you enjoy my stories. Thank you so very much! More will be forthcoming on Wednesdays :-) Thank you for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!

Fiondil · 28 February 2014 · Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Arafinwë was very foolish to run off on his own like that. Obviously Someone was looking out for him or he would be having a nice cozy little chat with Lord Námo right about now. *grin* It must be terrible not to remember who you are, to have no identity, so to speak. I really can't imagine what it has to feel like.

Author's reply

Arafinwë crashed emotionally, plain and simple. Apparently he hid things well enough that the healers didn't realize how far gone he was emotionally. I have to wonder if Namo hasn't had enough of the family of Finwë and really didn't want any more of them cluttering up his halls, so he helped arrange for a rescue. Who knows exactly who all was behind it? Arafinwë is just really lucky to have been rescued. I agree he must be terrified. Elves live so much in memory and to have little to no memory in which to live? That would be exceedingly difficult at best. Thank you so very much for taking the time to read and reivew. I appreciate it very much!

Larner · 26 February 2014 · Chapter 1: Chapter 1

He has reason to shield himself from the memories. I'm glad she came along when she did, and that he is not alone now.

Author's reply

His memories are quite horrible, no question about that. He indeed was extremely fortunate she came along when she did and was able to help him. Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!