Lovely scene with Yavanna.
Babies are such miracles! Beautiful descriptions.
Author's reply
Thank you very much!
Babies can bring healing and fulfillment and be pretty darn cute! Given what Tolkien said about the beauty of Finarfin's other children, I bet these little ones are gorgeous, too.
Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Fiondil
· 26 April 2014
· Chapter 9: Chapter 9
Even though it really wasn't funny, I had to laugh at Arafinwë's reaction to the smith's question about getting Faroniel pregnant. Ouch! Poor ellon! He does get flustered very easily, doesn't he?
I found the dream quite significant. Poor ellon! (I keep saying that) I know how he feels. Being the handicapped child in the family with brothers who could do things I could not, I had (and probably still have) self-image issues, just like Arafinwë, though, thankfully my parents never tried to compare me with my brothers or make me feel worthless, so I guess I'm one up on Arafinwë. At least he had Aulë to comfort him and you can't go wrong when a Vala's on your side, can you?
Good chapter, Ellie.
Author's reply
I thought it was funny what happened to Arafinwë, too :-) He is struggling so much in this story.
You turned out pretty awesome like Arafinwë did. It just goes to prove that our struggles often shape us into something unexpected and greater than we might ever have expected for ourselves.
Thanks so very much for reading and reviewing! I am most grateful for you taking the time to do so.
Twoflower2
· 25 April 2014
· Chapter 9: Chapter 9
Happy as I am for Laureher and Faroniel, this is such a mess. Two families! I hope that the consequences for all concerned won't be too dire. The story's title is, after all, optimistic. So there is some hope. Right?
Author's reply
There is hope, but hope takes many forms. I can't tell you anything about the two families or the consequences which may arise from such or I will give things away. So, keep reading :-)
Thanks so very much for reading and reviewing. I am most grateful, if unhelpful in my responses to reviews. LOL
Larner
· 25 April 2014
· Chapter 9: Chapter 9
I rejoice that he has found such a worthy foster uncle for the twins to come. I only hope no grief comes to Faroniel when he remembers his true place and rank.
Author's reply
He is very fortunate to have someone so insightful and helpful as Angadan to help out with raising the twins. We will have to see how things go later on.
Thanks for reading and reviewing. I really appreciate it!
Regan
· 24 April 2014
· Chapter 9: Chapter 9
Ow. Personally I've never hit my head on an anvil before, but it must hurt... a lot. I wonder what Galadriel will think. About the twins. Not the anvil. She'd probably just think that was stupid. Back to the twins and Galadriel. I can see it going either way. Given they are born right . Isn't there a rule about the two wives thing? Damn. So many questions. Well, Wednesday isn't too far off. I love this fic. And not just because it is something to get me through the horribly long, tedious week.
Author's reply
I think smacking one's head on an anvil would have hurt a lot.
Having lots of questions does keep people reading :-) LOL!
I'm pleased you are enjoying this fic so much. It has been an adventure writing it.
Thanks for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Lindelea
· 23 April 2014
· Chapter 9: Chapter 9
Sounds as if he's making a good beginning in wise fatherly choices!
Author's reply
He certainly is going to try to make the best choices and be the best dad he can be. Of course practice and theory can be two entirely different things as he apparently has completely forgotten. Then again, children round two often goes differently from the first batch of children one raises...
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Regan
· 19 April 2014
· Chapter 8: Chapter 8
Will it work? Having kids I mean? Will the Valar allow it ? Isn't it illegal to have two living wives? I wonder what Galadriel might think, if it does work(the kids thing)? So many questions. Anyways...I'd be most pleased if you updated it. Most, most pleased. Please. :D
Author's reply
This is a terrible answer, but you will have to wait and see what the Valar or anyone else has to say about it all and what eventually comes of these decisions that Arafinwe is making. He is a lonely, broken ellon who is acting according to what he remembers, but the problem is that he has incomplete information.
I try very hard to update on Wednesdays.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Monalex
· 18 April 2014
· Chapter 8: Chapter 8
Hello Ellie,
I'm sorry to say that this is the last time I will read this story at least until you finish it, so I won't have this mixed feelings in me. While I like the story, I can't stomach the thought of Arafinwe with someone else, living with her as his wife... when he just recently remember that he is married. How convenient for him that he could not connect with her, leaving him open in his mind to marry Faroniel... how easily he gave up. And now he wants hove children with her? Is he mad? This is just too irresponsible and my heart aches for the hurt that Earwen will suffer when she learns of this... of his betrayal... how he strayed from their love and on top of that when she learns that all of her children are dead with the exception of Galadriel. I sincerely don't know if I would be able to forgive this kind of betrayal, he conveniently forgot that those elves who remarried did so because their spouse refused to leave Mandos, just so he could be with Faroniel. I sincerely don't like this Arafinwe and hope that Earwen won't take him back for a long time (centuries even) for his desertion.
Hope you finish this story in a satisfactory manner for you.
Monalex
Author's reply
I am sorry that this story has upset you so. I actually finished writing the entire story before I ever began posting it, so use that information as you will in determining when you will read it.
Arafinwe is an ellon who was damaged physically, spiritually, and emotionally by many things and not just the war, as his flashes of memory repeatedly show. Unfortunately, there is nothing convenient about what has happened to him. He is operating within the confines of limited memories and is acting accordingly. He believes he is the last of the army of Valinor and that he is alone with no way to ever return to Valinor. He also has no incentive to return to Valinor, according to what he remembers of the dark and stressful times he experienced there. Earwen, from his current perspective, is just a lovely, nameless someone he has glimpsed in a dream or two.
If you read the Silmarillion, there are many elves who operate quite freely outside of the confines of the Laws and Customs of the Eldar and an awful lot of them are blood relatives of Arafinwe.
When you are ready to continue following him in this saga of loss and self-discovery and recovery, the story will be here waiting for you.
Thank you for reading and reviewing!
Fantasia
· 17 April 2014
· Chapter 8: Chapter 8
Oops! what a mess!...Faroniel will be happy for awhile, she deserves some happiness, but I'm afraid of the consequences.
Author's reply
Faroniel will not be the only one happy for a while. Arafinwe's is very lonely and bereft as well. Only time will tell if it was worth any consequences which may lie in the future...
Thanks so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Fiondil
· 17 April 2014
· Chapter 8: Chapter 8
That was a cute dream, if somewhat erotic at the end. Their union was inevitable. How long have they been sharing the bed like they were siblings or something? That couldn't last. Not when you have two very lonely people in the mix. And however brief the marriage will seem to Laurehér, for Farioniel it will last a lifetime and that's certainly long enough. But I fear there will be grave consequences for them all when this is over, yet, perhaps it will serve a higher doom than any of them can imagine. As they say, Eru draws straight with crooked lines.
Author's reply
After all of Arafinwe's thoughts on how presumptuous it is to think that mortal and elf marriage must serve some high purpose of doom, he certainly has no expectations for such. It would be unrealistic. He does indeed love Faroniel and she does indeed love him and their union was inevitable. Sometimes relationships can bring healing as well as fulfillment of more basic desires.
Eru does draw straight with crooked lines and He often does so without telling the writing implement that He is writing with it.
Thanks so very much for reading and reviewing. I do appreciate it very much!
Lindelea
· 16 April 2014
· Chapter 7: Chapter 7
Oh my! Laurehér has fangirls!
Author's reply
Yes, he sure does...and it is obviously a bit embarrassing. Poor guy!
Thanks for reading and reviewing!
Lindelea
· 16 April 2014
· Chapter 5: Chapter 5
A chilling parallel between two situations involving a bully, and someone who chose not to fight back. Whew.
Author's reply
Often Arafinwe's dreams parallel some experience in his current life in the mortal village. He has some pretty disturbing memories, doesn't he?
Thanks for reading and reviewing!
Lindelea
· 16 April 2014
· Chapter 4: Chapter 4
Faroniel is clever, even wise.
Half an Elf, when memory is lost? An interesting concept.
You are striving to become as you should be and not as others think you should be.
This would be a worthy goal for any of us.
Fascinating. Looking forward to reading more.
Author's reply
Faroniel is clever and wise, but at Arafinwe doesn't see this. He does not fully understand the sentiment toward Elves and the war.
Arafinwe was fortunate to have a Vala to instruct him in his youth. Perhaps that is where he learned much of his wisdom.
Thank you for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Larner
· 16 April 2014
· Chapter 8: Chapter 8
Well, if he had no memory of a daughter, it makes sense he did not search for one. As to what this relatively brief marriage to a mortal might mean to his marriage to Earwen--well, that remains to be seen, I suppose.
Author's reply
He definitely is digging himself a very deep hole with this relationship. Earwen still knows nothing of what has befallen him nor any news of the war. Much can happen in the years to come and will happen.
Thanks for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Lindelea
· 16 April 2014
· Chapter 4: Chapter 4
If he knew how to sail, then perhaps he knew other things as well.
That's what I was thinking!
Honestly, it's the height of irony to decide he's not a sailor, and then to have a deep-sea fishing dream...
(I am interrupted before reading about the visit to the village, so will try to get back later)
Author's reply
Arafinwe does not understand how damaged he really is and it is taking him a long time to process what he experiences and remembers. Poor guy! It is the height of irony, and it is terribly funny as well. How useless would it be to be a Vanyarin sailor?
Thank you very much for reading and reviewing. I'm glad you are enjoying this story :-)
Monalex
· 14 April 2014
· Chapter 7: Chapter 7
Hello Ellie,
I really like this story, though everytime I start a new chapter I'm in mortal fear of finding out what will happen now in his budding relationship with Faroniel...I wouldn't like to be Earwen at this point, would be horrible to discover your husband cheated on you with someone else, when he is supposed to be saving the world, even though he lost his memories...
Also poor ellon!! Having to deal with all that lusty looks of certain females and the glares of the males in the village...thank god he has his armor!!
Great chapter!!
Monalex
Author's reply
Hey Monalex, I appreciate you reading in spite of not knowing what you will face each chapter :-) I would not want to be Earwen either, but for a different reason. She has no knowledge whatsoever of what is transpiring in Middle-Earth and does not even know if her husband or any of the others who left are alive. Despite that huge uncertainty, she has to keep everyone in her kingdom functioning while none of them know what has or is transpiring in Middle-Earth either. So much of the labor force skilled and otherwise and the leadership left to go fight...
I am sure Arafinwe is most grateful for his armor at this point. This whole experience would be new to him even if he had all of his memories intact, but I don't think he would have handled it as well as he is now. Not that he necessarily is handling things that well anyway.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I am glad you are enjoying the story :-)
Lindelea
· 13 April 2014
· Chapter 3: Chapter 3
Alas, more guilt added to the burden he already bears, even if he does not consciously remember the details.
Author's reply
This elf is steeped in guilt. It is tough to be a military leader and king when one is as compassionate as he is. Perhaps he will eventually work his way through this.
Thank you for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Lindelea
· 13 April 2014
· Chapter 2: Chapter 2
There was only emptiness where his memories should have been.
How sad, that the names are familiar, but there are no memories that stir when he hears them.
Interesting, that she might have hidden his presence from searchers while he was unconscious. I wonder what will happen when he goes to search.
Author's reply
It is indeed very sad what he does not remember. He really has endured a lot in his long life.
I don't think that his presesnce was hidden from potential searchers by the one who found him. She really is a genuinely kind person.
Thank you for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Twoflower2
· 10 April 2014
· Chapter 7: Chapter 7
After reading every new chapter, I invariably think: "Poor, poor Arafinwe. And poor Faroniel. I wonder where it can go from now on." We know that canonically Arafinwe is supposed to return to Valinor (because he walks there with Finrod), but I am not at all sure what is going to happen in this story. Which is a good thing. Cringeworthy situations A. finds himself in this chapter are probably a unique experience for an elf-lord. And who would think that armor normally used for the defence against Balrogs etc. would be put on to defend oneself against over-eager women and jealous husbands :)
Author's reply
The War of Wrath lasted for a long time and who knows what all really happened during it? The situations certainly were "cringeworthy". I like the way you put that. I seriously doubt he ever before experienced such things as an elf-lord. Poor guy! At least he had armor to put on to protect himself!
Thank you very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Fiondil
· 9 April 2014
· Chapter 7: Chapter 7
Poor ellon, having to put up with females leering at him and discussing his many fine attributes where he can hear, but Faroniel's sister was way out of line. Must be hormones or something. *grin* Laurehér is wise to armor himself. I certainly would have.
Author's reply
I'm sure Faroniel's sister was not the only one experiencing surging hormones. Poor Arafinwe! Armor can be useful in many forms of conflict, as he is discovering!
Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Larner
· 9 April 2014
· Chapter 7: Chapter 7
There is a point at which such talk goes far beyond flattering to insulting, and I think he's found it. Tathariel should be spanked for her own behavior! Don't blame him for arming himself, by the way. I'd have done so, too, at that point!
Author's reply
Oh, he definitely found it insulting and shocking. He was totally unprepared for such behavior as he witnessed. Faroniel may have thought he was overreacting, but he certainly doesn't think so!
Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Lindelea
· 8 April 2014
· Chapter 1: Chapter 1
Powerfully written. The War of Wrath was wasteful and senseless, and one has to feel for this desolate king in the aftermath of the battle... Not surprised that he's lost most of his memory in the trauma and injury.
Interested to see who this woman is, and how long it will take his people to trace him.
Author's reply
Thank you very much! The War of Wrath was horrible with so many thousands who had never fought before going to battle for so many years. I know he was not the only one to suffer for his experiences in the war.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Larner
· 7 April 2014
· Chapter 6: Chapter 6
Alas that he does not remember his proper wife save in the color of her hair. I hope he does not break both this woman's heart and his own through his actions.
I can certainly appreciate how his rapid healing would astound the Men of the village.
Author's reply
At least he does remember her hair color if nothing else. It is interesting what he does and doesn't recall and how he recalls it as well as how it influences his behavior. He really is more damaged than he realizes. His body has healed well, though in spite of everything so that is something in his favor at least.
Thanks for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Larner
· 7 April 2014
· Chapter 5: Chapter 5
Wrong brother, of course. And Belegon has apparently never learned either wisdom or restraint. He certainly did not show himself well on that occasion.
Author's reply
Definitely the wrong brother, but the poor Elf has such a limited frame of reference. He really is doing the best he can with limited information. Belegon is scared and he lets that rule his behavior, at poor Laureher's expense.
Thanks for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Fiondil
· 5 April 2014
· Chapter 6: Chapter 6
I like his analysis of Finrod's motives for helping Beren with his quest and even be willing to die for him as being partly due to his guilt over his brother and Andreth and their unrequited love. I'd never thought of it in those terms before. Whether it's true or not — and if he ever is reunited with Finrod it would be interesting to hear their conversation on the subject — I think his thinking in these terms will influence how he acts toward Faroniel from now on.
Author's reply
I had never before considered this take on Finrod's motives myself until Arafinwe revealed them. It is weird when characters do that. I would love to be a fly on the wall if he ever does meet Finrod again and discuss this with him. It will be interesting to see what influence Arafinwe's thoughts and beliefs will have on him.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I know you are busy and I appreciate it very much!