News Resources
Login
Become a member
Help
Search
|
|
| About Us News Resources
Login
Become a member
Help
Search
|
|
|
| The End of Dark Days by Edoraslass | 8 Review(s) |
|---|---|
| Larner | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 10/12/2007 |
| A satisfying tale, but feels as if it could go on and on, of course. Very nice, Edoraslas. I've always loved Mags. | |
| Violin Ghost | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 8/19/2007 |
| This is beautifully-written, and I must say, I'm glad to get some closure. It's also great to see Nanny again -- I've missed her, and I've been checking Under My Wing every once in a while, just in case an alert didn't make it to my inbox. Nanny's protectiveness of her little rabbit is as touching as it ever was, and watching the two old friends converse was nice as well. I hope we'll see Nanny interacting with Faramir -- it would be interesting to see how they talk, now that Faramir is a fully-grown man (with a lover of his own!). I like that Nanny doesn't believe Denethor could commit such a grievous act -- it says a lot about what he was like before. He, quite obviously, was not a monster, not an abusive parent, and not a lunatic. I'm glad. Thank you for a wonderful story, and hoping for more, Violin Ghost Author Reply: Well, thank you! And nope, you haven't missed anything - my output's just been a little slow lately, sorry to day. I suppose my brain's recharging. :) I do intend to give Nanny and Faramir some discussion - they'll certainly have a lot to talk about, won't they? - because I myself am curious to see how they'll talk with each other! I suspect Nanny will, to a point, treat him like he's still no taller than her knee. And yep, Nanny has her Denethor issues, but she'd never believe him capable of actually physically hurting either one of his sons, especially not like THAT. But I have a feeling she wasn't as shocked as you might think to find that Denethor had lost his grip on reality. Thank you so much! | |
| Daynawayna | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 6/2/2007 |
| Wonderful story, Edoraslass! I'm not familiar with Nanny, which made the story fun to read because I had to discover if she had been Mag's Nanny (Mag appeared "young" to me in Ch.1) or Nanny to Boromir and Faramir. She is well written and I love how she still worries and fusses over him, eventhough her services have long-since ended. :) And silly me, I went to discover more of your writing before I even reviewed this, the 1st story I read! LOL By the way, I know what an OC is, but what is an OFC? F being female? that's all I can come up with! Keep up the great work! Dayna Author Reply: Mag always appears young to me, no matter how old she actually is - have you read Ann's other Mag stories? Thank you! I do enjoy writing Nanny, and she and Mag work so well together. And yep, the F is for "female". | |
| Bodkin | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 6/2/2007 |
| Thank goodness for Mag. Her presence throughout it all lends perspective. But she's right to wonder about how those who obeyed Denethor would cope with what they did - unless they could live with the 'just obeying orders' argument. I can't help but feel for the kid with the good boots - a sacrifice to the greater good. In a way. I'm sure Nanny will cast a most critical gaze over Eowyn. I only hope she lives up to expectations. (Doubtless she has a protective Nanny of her own to help her understand. It would be interesting to have the two surrogate mothers meet ...) Author Reply: Yes, Mag is always so grounded and steady, she's just the one you want around when everything is falling apart. I know, I feel so badly for that poor boy with his new boots, too! And he was so proud to be helping. He should have evacuated, poor dear. I'm pretty sure Nanny will be fine with Eowyn....eventually.:) Thanks, Bodkin! | |
| harrowcat | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 6/2/2007 |
| Oh these three chapters are great Edoraslass - can't wait for that meeting! Author Reply: Thank you, and I'll pass on Ann's thanks as well! I'm not sure when the meeting will be, but I'm sure I'll get there one day! | |
| Denise | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 6/2/2007 |
| But- but- Wait! How can this be "Complete"??? I want to see Nanny and Mag figure out the King is Thorongil-who-Nanny-didn't-like. I want to see Nanny visit Faramir, and ambush Eowyn, and meet Pippin and Merry, and bump into Prince Imrahil! Truly, this was a wonderful glimpse of two dear friends reuniting. The impact of the war on Nanny's family was so sad, but realistic; and Mag's thoughts and descriptions of the horrible events she witnessed were very chilling. Are Nanny's husband and son both professional soldiers? How do they manage after the war? I can't imagine Nanny staying away from Dol Amroth any longer than she has to, but it will probably be a while before her husband and son heal enough to travel. Please, do give us more! | |
| Tigger | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 6/1/2007 |
| Fair warning to Eowyn? Now where would the fun be in doing that? ;o) Of all the things to see when checking tonight, this was a lovely surprise. I've been wondering if you'd touch on Nanny and after the siege of Minas Tirith, but to see a combination of you *and* Ammarwalk dealing w/this...I am very much looking forward to seeing where this goes. How long till they put two and together and realize Thorongil = Aragorn? That is a moment I will be waiting for w/bated breath. :oD Once again, this was a wonderful surprise to discover tonight. Thanks Ladies and looking forward to more!! :o) Author Reply: Eowyn's probably kind of relieved she doesn't have to deal with a mother-in-law, and then she's going to have to meet Mag AND Nanny! :) I though Ann had a story where Mag figured out that Thorongil and Aragorn were the same person, but I can't find it. Hmmmmmm.... Glad you enjoyed this! Thank you! | |
| Linda Hoyland | Reviewed Chapter: 3 on 6/1/2007 |
| I loved your description of Faramir's healing and Denethor's madness Author Reply: That's Ann's work - a great deal of this chapter is Ann's - and I think it's lovely, too. Thank you! | |