News Resources
Login
Become a member
Help
Search
|
|
| About Us News Resources
Login
Become a member
Help
Search
|
|
|
| Virtuella's Idiosyncratic Literary Criticisms by Virtuella | 2 Review(s) |
|---|---|
| Larner | Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 6/12/2009 |
| In many ways the House of Tom Bombadil is also a locus amoenus, as here, surrounded by rain and the Old Forest, with the influence of the Withywindle close at hand, is also found a hallowed place of safety and regeneration, a lesser one than Caras Gadadhon, but in many ways a foreshadowing of the later visit to Lorien. And in discussing water as a symbol of death, do not forget that the Sundering Sea serves this function, also. Frodo leaves to find healing and regeneration, if he can accept it once he is brought where it might come to him; but in so doing he becomes as one who is dead to those who loved him. Only Sam has the hope of seeing him once more in the body; for all others he and Bilbo are indeed lost forever to them. And in the rolling back of the silver rain-curtain, we have another symbol of spiritual cleansing that helps wash away Frodo's humanity, preparing him to accept the new reality he knows as a guest of the immortals, not quite an immortal himself as they are but still sharing in much of their reality for the time remaining to him. Again, a most thoughtful essay, and one that speaks deeply to my own love of mythological imagery. Author Reply: I had thought whether or not Bombadil's house was a locus amoenus, but it seemed to me to be a bit too - rustic? Certainly someone stomping about in huge big boots is not what you expect to find in the locus amoenus, though Goldberry, of course, fits in nicely. Good point about the Sundering Sea and its connection with death. Thanks again, and I hope you get a good nights' sleep! | |
| Dreamflower | Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 6/5/2009 |
| Oh, this is quite excellent! I've been aware of some of the symbolism of some of the bodies of water mentioned, but I had never before looked at it as a motif! Your evidence is quite compelling. I think that the association of water with the Good Guys can't be denied; and even the fact that water can present a danger to both friend and foe aligns it with "good". I am reminded of the Narnia chronicles, when the children ask if Aslan is safe. The answer was, no he wasn't safe, but he was Good. That which is good carries its own sort of danger to mortals. Two things I would ask you about: the longing of Frodo and Sam for water and light when they are in Mordor. And the Ent-draughts-- I'd love to hear your opinion about the Ent-draughts! Author Reply: Oh, thanks for reminding me. I had completley forgotten about the Ent-draught. I've added a bit under "Water and magic." I think it is one of the most interesting things about LOTR, the way the scenery is used to advance the story. Thanks for your comments! | |