News Resources
Login
Become a member
Help
Search
|
|
| About Us News Resources
Login
Become a member
Help
Search
|
|
|
| Thain Peregrin I: the First Days by Garnet Took | 65 Review(s) |
|---|---|
| Freyalyn | Reviewed Chapter: 999999 on 5/4/2014 |
| Excellent story - I loved your attention to detail and characterisation. Author Reply: Thank you so much. I'm glad you enjoyed it. | |
| Larner | Reviewed Chapter: 999999 on 4/27/2014 |
| We'll look for the new story. And again, welcome back again! Author Reply: Thanks. It's good to be back. :) I'm debating looking at what I have written so far on the new yet this evening but I may be too tired to think clearly about it. I need to do some serious work on what's already written and there's plenty more to write. I do need to jump into with both feet now that there's no other stories to distract me. | |
| Larner | Reviewed Chapter: Epilogue 2 on 4/27/2014 |
| Ah, and I hope that the naysayers find themselves changing their minds as Pippin proves himself. Author Reply: Oh they will. All those that matter anyway. Thanks for being there through the whole thing and thank for the encouragement. | |
| shirebound | Reviewed Chapter: Epilogue 2 on 4/27/2014 |
| I don’t ask for the position for the glory and recognition of the title. I ask for it as an opportunity to serve the land and people I love. Perfect. I love the final line so much. This has been a totally delightful story. Author Reply: Thank you so much, Shirebound for sticking with me through the whole thing. I'm glad this last bit rang true and that you loved it. I was typing like a madwoman this morning on too little sleep and wasn't 100% sure how well this was turning out. | |
| Lindelea | Reviewed Chapter: Epilogue 2 on 4/27/2014 |
| Popping a sticky treat in your mouth just before you have to speak (like just before the phone rings, in our world...). Sounds so familiar! Several had left, or didn't seem to approve, eh? Hopefully Pippin will be able to win them over without too much grief. This has been a lovely story, and I'm sad to see it end! Thank you for the treat. Author Reply: I think I must have been channelling all my annoyance when the phone rings at work when I've taken a big bite of something. It happens all the time. :) He'll win all those who truly matter over. He the charming Peregrin Took after all. Thanks for liking it enough to review. I had a great time writing it and now maybe I'm ready to finish that other one thats been waiting six years to get done. | |
| Larner | Reviewed Chapter: 14 on 4/26/2014 |
| Ah, the perfect afternoon and evening. How proud of his dedication and love for his wife Frodo would have been of him. And he's proved himself to have the makings of an excellent Thain indeed! Author Reply: This was an enjoyable chapter for the author as well as for the characters. :) Yes, I think Frodo would have been proud of Pip on several counts. Glad you liked it and thanks for sticking with me on this one. | |
| Lindelea | Reviewed Chapter: 14 on 4/25/2014 |
| At last, I can review! I read this last night but haven't had a chance before now to leave a good word. Pippin's just like a kid anticipating Christmas! Very sweet. Regi would probably be delighted to fetch him another plate! Maybe two! “Are there a lot?” asked Pippin. Reginard shrugged his shoulders. “It depends on your definition of a lot,” he said. Very precise of Regi... can't go wrong there... Nice ruling in the case of the wandering bull. I love Farry's summary of good behaviour. And Pippin as an eternally silly, irrepressible baby brother. The last of the preparations and the rest of the chapter made me grin. Lovely! Author Reply: I'm glad you liked it. Regi is a very good balance for Pippin and vice versa. When it comes to certain things, pip will never grow up. Glad you liked the decision on the bull. I just thought of it and threw it in. Glad you liked the last bit. I had way too much fun writing it. | |
| Dreamflower | Reviewed Chapter: 14 on 4/24/2014 |
| *grin* A perfect surprise for Diamond! You really made me smile with this chapter! Oh: I have to congratulate you on something else. Coincidentally, on the LJ community fanficrants, just today, I had mentioned in a comment that I'd only seen the word "pique" used correctly in a fanfic once. Someone else said they had *never* seen it used correctly. Well, now, for the second time, I have seen it used correctly!! Whee! (It's not a common word, so I just had to mention it! Isn't it funny how things like that crop up?) Author Reply: Glad the chapter made you grin. The last half just wrote itself. It was like they were having a confessional moment and telling me, "First we did this and then that happened and, oh by the way, somewhere in there we had that wonderful wine and ate all those fantastic nibbles." I'm excited that you were impressed with the use of the word "pique". I use it a lot in just the way I used it in the story. I just I'd never noticed that most people have either not heard it or never heard it used correctly. It is sometimes interesting how you come across something rare and then it just keeps cropping up. Glad you have enjoyed the story and thank you for sticking with me through it and faithfully reviewing. It really helped. | |
| shirebound | Reviewed Chapter: 14 on 4/24/2014 |
| It's interesting to think about the parallels between Pippin's life as Thain and Aragorn's as King. They're both guardians of land and people who trust and respect them, and both are making decisions with as much wisdom as they can... with good people to help them every step of the way. This is a very loving and lovely chapter. I'm so happy for Pippin and Diamond, and the Tooklands, and all of the Shire that such joyous and peaceful times have come at last. Author Reply: I've alway thought that Pippin and Aragorn had a lot more in common than most would think. Pippin really paid attention to how Aragorn governed and tried to learn from it. Also, I've always viewed Pippin as more intelegent than most people gave him credit for. :) Pippin and Diamond lover each other madly, even though they have a very dark time ahead. Diamond eventually has to work through her own issues and will eventually remember that Pippin loves her as much as he showed her on this day early in his Thainship. Yes, I'm getting ready to finish that trilogy that covers the building of the Thain's family. :) Thanks for sticking with me through this whole thing and thanks for the encouraging reviews. | |
| Larner | Reviewed Chapter: 13 on 4/24/2014 |
| How well he's planning for the next day! I hope he and Diamond find it well worthwhile! Author Reply: I hope so too. And I hope I can write it the way they deserve. Thanks for reviewing so faithfully | |