|About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search|
|Ada's Little Girl by daw the minstrel||34 Review(s)|
|perelleth||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 12/9/2017|
|This was hilarious Daw, the banter among the three of them is priceless...Ithilden won`t lose his composure, adn Eilian won`t miss a chance of ribbing him and then he falls into the pit as well....a comedic jewel, with the counterpoint of how sinnarn's death affected them. Lovely, thanks!|
Author Reply: Poor Ithilden. And yet, he survives it all with his confidence intact. At least on the surface. I guess underneath he's fighting off some fear and guilt.
|perelleth||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 12/9/2017|
|Oh, this is priceless! Love the dry deadpan way in which you now write Ithilden, and how you get into his neatly organized head, but still manage some sympathy for his need for control and also the way he is a prisoner of his own sense of responsibility. |
the "He thinks nothing dare attack him" comment made me laugh. really, what can be wrong? A simple trip indeed, poor elf!
Author Reply: Thank you, Perelleth. I've worked with these characters for so long that I feel like I know all of them through and through. It took me a while though. In particular, it took me a while to get to understand Ithilden. I had to write from his POV to do it.
|sofiab||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 3/14/2016|
|I was coming to your page here to reread some stories, as I do from time to time because I love them so much, and I nearly screamed with excitement when I saw this story and realized that 1)its a recently new one you wrote and 2) I hadn't read it yet! (Which makes me sad because it means its been that long since I've reread anything you wrote)|
So needless to say, I was so completely THRILLED to read another story of yours with these wonderful characters! And it was such a cute little read! I loved the line in the first chapter about Ithiliden being surprised by the treachery of the world. Because of course the world would be against him personally! I love the mischeviousness of Eilian and Legolas and the general lighthearted feel to this little story.
Still trying to process my thoughts but thank you so much for writing! I know you've said before that you feel like you've said all you've had to say on these characters but if at anytime you want to write more I will always be in line to read them!
Also congrats on publishing your book- thats so exciting!
|Ana||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 12/2/2015|
|I can't even describe how happy I was when I realised there were new stories written by you. :D It's like running into an old friend. :)|
Author Reply: I wish there were more stories! I just seem to be out of ideas right now.
And seeing SoA reviewers again feels like meeting old friends to me too. :-)
|Alice||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 11/22/2015|
|I knew you weren't going to name the baby! I actually kind of thought the story would cut off before the birth so you could avoid the whole thing all together.|
This was great to see though I really, really hope that Ithilden does let her go more than a league from the strong hold. As I recall, Ithilden had to learn to deal with his son being different from him so I suspect that even if unnamed daughter is a sweet child, he will still have to learn how to deal with her being different (and less cooperative) than his wife.
So, if your loyal readers name the baby, will we get any Uncle Legolas and his nieces fanfic? Like maybe he takes them camping? Or they have a tea party? Or he has to rescue unnamed baby from Loriel leading her off into trouble? In my head, Alfirin and Ithilden name her Aerlinn or Glirwen or something like that for song (since they named their son "story").
I'm so glad I came and checked the website today and saw this up! Thank you so much for writing it. I love when you come back and play with these characters because your OCs mean as much to me as many of Tolkien's own characters. These stories are beloved to me in the same way that my Tamora Pierce books are in that they were my teenaged hero stories during my teen years.
Author Reply: I really like Aerlinn as a name but I think I already used it. I'd have to look to be sure, but I think that when the little boys throw mud and snowballs, it's at Miriwen and Aerlinn. And then, Tonduil marries her. I think.
But you have a good sense of how I picture this little girl. I think she'll be sweet and fairly docile, but maybe have a stubborn streak. And I strongly suspect that Ithilden will occasionally wonder if she should be allowed to play with Loriel. LOL
So I picture this little scene in which both girls are beginning to hang out with boys. They're at a party on the Green, and boys ask them to go somewhere and Loriel says let's ask my Naneth. And Unnamed Girl says Your Naneth? We always ask your Adar. And Loriel says Not this time.
Sadly that's not enough to make a story. I'm waiting for editorial feedback at the moment and so I'm not writing, which is making me restless, so I wish I had a story, but not yet.
Glad you liked it, Alice.
|Naneth||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 10/23/2015|
|What a delightful story! So happy to have the chance to see that little girl be born, a glimpse of Thranduil as an indulgent Grandpa, and the brothers on an adventure. I am also enjoying imagining the keepers reaction to this trip!|
Author Reply: Thank you, Naneth. The keepers are a pain to deal with sometimes. I mean for me, not just for the Legolas and Eilian, though for them too, I suppose. Anyway, as a writer, I have to dump them sometimes in order to have a story.
Grandpa Thranduil is my wish fulfillment. I want grandchildren! And when I have them, I intend to indulge them for all I'm worth.
Good to see you again.
|Lmw||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 10/17/2015|
|I have been rereading Larrkin's stories, and now that I have finished those, I went looking for more elves. I haven't been to SoA in a long time.|
I was so thrilled to see your name with a new story! I found your stories years ago and have read and reread them many times. I love your elves, and their interactions and sense of family, even in times of stress.
I hope (selfishly) that you can continue to write about this family... !
Congrats on the published novel!
Author Reply: Thank you, Lmw. I had a good time being with these characters again. I spent so much time with them in my head that they feel real to me. My beta once told me that my stories were really about family, and I think she's right.
I hope to write more about them. I just need to get the time and creative energy.
Also, thank you for the congrats. I think of the novel's characters as young Eilian and Ithilden born into a different world. That made them much easier to write.
|Noor||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 10/9/2015|
|Thank you Daw,|
Have been away so lovely to read the ending. I do so enjoy reading about the three brothers - as adults they are even closer. I went back and read all your other stories after reading the first chapter of this one. Thank you for the creativity and emotion you have put in to your tales.
Author Reply: Thanks, Noor.
As you probably know, I've been working on original fic, and I keep reminding myself that it's the emotion that matters. Action is good, and plot is necessary, but none of that matters unless the characters (and, I hope, the readers) feel something.
Hope your time away was for something pleasant.
|Bodkin||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 9/13/2015|
|Is it mean to hope that Ada's little girl gives him as much trouble as Ada's now-unfortunately-deceased son did? I suspect he'll find it much harder to deal with, too. Pouts and eyelashes and whines of 'but, Adaaaaaaa ...'|
I think Eilian and Legolas enjoyed Ithilden's troubles. Perhaps a little more than they should have shown.
But Sera! What an irritating little madam. Born to convince elves that that should keep their distance from Men.
What a fun tale. I'll keep my fingers crossed for more.
Author Reply: Ada's now-unfortunately-deceased son
Luckily for me, he didn't stay deceased, thanks to you, Bodkin!
Eilian and Legolas do enjoy seeing Ithilden losing control of things. Why not? I would. I'd keep my mouth shut though.
Sera is not someone I'd want around, mostly because she's so determined to put herself in an unhappy situation. But then, people do that. You look at them and you think, That's not going to work. But they can't seem to hear you when you say that. I guess some folks do have to learn for themselves.
Glad you liked it, Bodkin.
|Lianna||Reviewed Chapter: 2 on 9/12/2015|
|Lovely ending, but you have to write another story now.|
You didn't tell us the new baby's name!
Author Reply: You know, it's odd, but I find it really hard to give characters their names. If I were writing a story set in our world, I guess I could use the phone book or something, but in Tolkien, it gets really hard to create a name that feels right but is easy for the reader to pronounce and remember.
All of which is a long way to say, I don't know the baby's name!
I'm glad you liked it.