Reviews (227)

Larner · 4 January 2007 · Chapter 5: Healing Hands

Another pair I recall vividly. And I suspect my comments from the last time are here. The comfort of Aragorn's hands easing the weary feet, followed by the realization of how empty Frodo's life has become as those who love him seek an easing for him. How deeply Frodo is loved by Aragorn and Arwen and all they represent.

Larner · 4 January 2007 · Chapter 4: The Best We Have

Appreciation and respect grow between these travelers and the Hobbits, as is right and proper. Wonderful!

Larner · 4 January 2007 · Chapter 3: Stubborn As Can Be

And another Hobbit is now converted into loving bananas. Wonderful! And I LOVE banana bread.

Larner · 4 January 2007 · Chapter 2: Treasures

Frodo Baggins, one of the most responsible of Hobbits ever to be born. And worried about Bilbo going broke? Poor feverish lad.

Larner · 4 January 2007 · Chapter 1: Seeing Isn't Always Believing

I remember reading the second one, but not the first and third before. Three good looks at our beloved Frodo needing more aid than he would ask for himself. Stubborn Baggins!

Dreamflower · 4 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

Aww...that's such a beautiful comparison, and not one that had occurred to me before. But how true, that both of them were in unique situations--to see a dear friend overcome by the power of that Thing at the very point of Its destruction. Well done!

Elemmírë · 4 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

This was beautiful, Shirebound, and so very PERFECT! I can't imagine their conversation going any differently. "I lost Isildur to the Ring, but you did not lose Frodo.” “No, sir," Sam said with a relieved smile. "Except for that one moment, when the Ring took over at last, I didn’t ever lose him. Gandalf said not to, and I never did.” It's good that Elrond now has someone he can discuss his own situation with after hundreds of years gone by. He must have himself at one point been blaming himself as Sam was, wondering what would have happened if he'd stopped Isildur in some manner. But alas, poor Elrond has had a very long time to think such things over. If Frodo was meant to carry the One Ring, then perhaps Elrond was meant to endure such a situation at the Cracks of Doom and such guilt himself all those years ago--if only for the sake of being able to truly understand and help one guilty hobbit, Sam, cope with the aftermath. I'm glad Elrond had that talk with Sam ... that they could both help each other. Sam needed that conversation and I'm glad you wrote it! :D ~Elemmírë~

Pearl Took · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

Well done indeed, Samwise Gamgee! And well done shirebound as well :-)

Pearl Took · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 7: Half Elven

LOL The wonder and marvels of the common cold!

Pearl Took · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 6: Trust

Cool twist! Well Done!!

Pearl Took · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 5: Healing Hands

*sigh* Wonderful!

Pearl Took · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 4: The Best We Have

Aw, warm, cuddled up hobbits! They are very protective of Frodo!

Pearl Took · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 3: Stubborn As Can Be

“Did you only bring one?” Perfect!

Pearl Took · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 1: Seeing Isn't Always Believing

Wonderful as always :-)

Periantari · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

ooo how lovingly written! I love Sam comfort so much! THis was written so very well ...i appreciate Elrond's words of wisdom to Sam and glad that Sam realized this: I didn’t ever lose him. Gandalf said not to, and I never did.” awww he never did indeed. :) ::snuggles Sam:: =)

Frodo Baggins · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

Oh my goodness! *hugging Sam* He's so wonderful! The poor dear with feeling guilty and all. :( I am glad Elrond could persuade that stubborn Gamgee that it wasn't his fault. The dear, he doesn't realise how much he did for Frodo, how Frodo wouldn't have made it without him. He just was there the whole time, and gave Frodo the strength and will to go on. And your prowess as a writer is not to be matched! I love all of your stories, and this is a shining jewel among treasures. :) I am not flattering, it's true. Namarie, and hannon le. God Bless, Frodo Baggins

Antane · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

As soon as Sam awoke, and was assured that he was alive, and not dreaming, he insisted on tottering to Frodo’s room. Once there, he simply refused to leave... As the days passed, the staff of healers acknowledged among themselves that Sam seemed to draw strength just from watching his master sleep... It's good that Sam has some peace, doing his favorite thing, watching over his Frodo and Elrond's talk was good for him - the one person who would understand Sam's guilt. I hope they were able to talk again at some point when Sam and Frodo both discover that the battle wasn't over after all. Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Andrea · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

He had followed Frodo to the end of all things, and was with him still. Beautifully written, Shirebound! Who else but Elrond would understand best what Sam experienced at Mt. Doom! What would have happened at the Cracks of Doom if Sam hadn't been there? I think it was of great help for Frodo that Sam simply *was there*. To keep him grounded and to prevent him from doing something horrible, something mad. I remember that scene in the movie where Frodo obviously wanted to let go, but Sam convinced him to (literally) hold on! Sam should not blame himself. He should be proud of what he achieved. Unfortunately, Sam reacts very much like Frodo in that respect! Thank you :)

Queen Galadriel · 3 January 2007 · Chapter 8: Finding Peace

I love these little ficlets, Shirebound, and I'm thrilled you keep adding to them! This one is so sweet. Poor Sam, that would bother me, too, I think. But Elrond's right, and he knows what it was like. I'm glad he was there to comfort our Sam. God bless, Galadriel

Queen Galadriel · 16 August 2006 · Chapter 6: Trust

Ooo! Another one I haven't read! And what an intriguing AU and a sweet scene to show us from it. I love it! God bless, Galadriel

Queen Galadriel · 16 August 2006 · Chapter 7: Half Elven

LOL! Oh, that is priceless, Shirebound! LOL! I know it shouldn't be that funny, but I can't help it! Poor Elrond! LOL! I found this when I needed it most, as it happens, because right now I and about half my family are sick with a real pain of a cold. This really makes you think twice about it! LOL! God bless, Galadriel

Antane · 22 July 2006 · Chapter 7: Half Elven

Cute! Poor Elrond. I'm sure this is one new experience he feels he could have done without! Love that Frodo wants to keep him company. Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Antane · 22 July 2006 · Chapter 6: Trust

Interesting story - like this alot - I explored the same idea of Faramir going to the fire with the hobbits in my own huge epic so much welcome the idea here. :) Namarie, God bless, Antane

Antane · 22 July 2006 · Chapter 5: Healing Hands

Always nice to see Frodo getting some TLC! He needs so much of it, poor dear. Namarie, God bless, Antane :)

Lindelea · 22 July 2006 · Chapter 7: Half Elven

LOL! Trust shirebound to write an Elf-tale that a hobbit-fan can devour with glee! “The Third Age *is* ending, you impertinent hobbit,” Aragorn chuckled (I loved that.) “The Third Age is ending, you impertinent hobbit,” Aragorn chuckled “On the contrary, having a cold is no doubt quite intriguing for an Elf. Someone as long-lived as Lord Elrond no doubt believed that he would never encounter such new and fascinating experiences ever again.” This was intriguing for the reader to contemplate as well, and the ending was perfect and good for a chuckle! Thanks!