Forging Hope by Ellie

Reviews (89)

Write a review

obsidianj · 5 August 2018 · Chapter 14: Chapter 14

A fulfilling and heartbreaking story. Poor Arafinwe, having found and then lost so much. Reading this I am reminded why mortals should not strive for immortality. Having to endure losses like this for all eternity would be too much.

obsidianj · 4 August 2018 · Chapter 9: Chapter 9

Sorry, I'm not good with riddles like this. I'm not from the US. What is P.E.? I feel glad for the kids that Gandalf is there and recognizes kind of what is going on. Poor Kaylee, it is hard to go to bed without your mom and dad in a strange world.

obsidianj · 30 July 2018 · Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Finally, I get back to reading fanfiction. I have the notification for this story in my inbox for years. I'm glad I started reading. This story is of to a good start. Now I just have to remember the family connections of Arafinwe.

mystarlight · 26 July 2018 · Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I am mesmerized by your another amazing story. It is difficult to put it down. Thank you

Artelemnar Fëanestar · 22 July 2017 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

I absolutely loved this! I don't know what to say... Those 6+ years of writing were a hundred percent worth it, in my opinion. I'm going to be rereading this many times in the years to come :)

May · 5 August 2016 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

This was a very interesting story, well written and incredibly original, I have never read something like this in the fadom, and I have read a lot of fanfiction😔. I hope this message gets to you.

Anonymous · 29 April 2016 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

This is a wonderfull story that brought tears to my eyes more than once. Please continue, you and the other members of your group, to write such stories as have been filling all my leasure time for a while. I wish I could join, but I have no talent for writing, although I think I might he good at proof reading. I think I would call myself Colleenneth, lol.

Siiw · 6 May 2015 · Chapter 6: Chapter 6

Poor, silly Laureher, you can be so right and still so WRONG. "Perhaps if two people love each other, then they should be together and their races should not matter. Did not all love come from Eru?" <-This is, I feel, a deep truth that goes far beyond this story.

Siiw · 1 April 2015 · Chapter 4: Chapter 4

One must wonder what Arafinwë's life would have been like if he wasn't a prince and king of the Noldor. It must have been a lot like the life he experiences now as a smith. These experiences are bound to make him only more wise, having seen life from this angle.

Siiw · 26 March 2015 · Chapter 3: Chapter 3

This made me cry again, even re-reading it. I can't imagine this level of guilt.

Author's reply

He has had too much to process and come to terms with in so little time. And being an ellon with a conscience has not helped him in this. Thanks for reading and reviewing!

Siiw · 26 March 2015 · Chapter 2: Chapter 2

It strikes me how much more comfortable Elves are with physical contact between strangers of opposite genders than what humans are.

Author's reply

elves have a different perspective on life and I think a more practical one. Thanks for reading and reviewing!

Siiw · 24 March 2015 · Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I finally came back to this story, to re-read and review. It is so very emotional. This is a familiar character seen from a new angle. Arafinwë is usually a king, and an unusually wise one, but here he is just a person, wounded and afraid. :(

Author's reply

He is just a person and he has much to rediscover about who this person really is. Sorry for the delay in replying. RL presented me many challenges the last few months and then I fell and broke my shoulder and injured my wrist a few days ago. Your reviews have brightened my days. Thank you so very much for them!

Lindelea · 17 July 2014 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

A satisfying ending. Thank you for this engrossing tale. I'm very glad that he was reunited with the son who was earlier denied him, and that his family did not turn against him as he feared. In a sense, it's as if he's been absolved of his unwitting guilt, after living with the consequences for so long. Or maybe it is as Eonwë said, that Morgoth's evil was turned to unforeseen good.

Author's reply

Morgoth's evil was turned to unforseen good. I felt that Arafinwe needed a happy ending because so much else in his life has been a struggle. Thank you very much for reading, enjoying and letting me know. I apologize for the lateness of this reply.

Fiondil · 13 July 2014 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

This was certainly a difficult situation for Arafinwë and it's understandable the reactions of his other children to his news about Aicanáro and his love for Faroniel. Still, I think, in the end, they all will be the better for it. I'm sure Finrod will be very friendly toward his half-brother and his family, being who he is. The others might take a little longer to come to acceptance, but they'll get there eventually. Whether Aicanáro and his family ever get used to their status is another story (literally and figuratively speaking). I really enjoyed this, both times, Ellie. You do Arafinwë well and he's a character we don't see much of in fanfics. There really should be more such stories about him, but at least we have yours to enjoy. Thanks for letting me help you with this story. It was fun to discuss what might happen and why and what we should do about it.

Author's reply

I agree that Finrod will be among the first to be friendly, but I also think that the youngest daughter will be accepting as well, if for no other reason, than to make her atto happy, because she is very protective of him and very close to him. I very much enjoyed bouncing ideas off of you concerning this story and the ensuing discussions. I hate it took so many years to get this written. Thanks for hanging in there with me! It was a tough tale to tell and I am proud of the way it turned out.

Fiondil · 13 July 2014 · Chapter 19: Chapter 19

Arafinwë and Eárendil are funny here in spite of the seriousness of the situation in which they (and everyone else) find themselves. Aicanáro was wise not to let Arafinwë near his forge, though, even though I suspect that Arafinwë sobered up real quickly when he realized who the smith was. And at least now Eärendil realizes that he's not alone in his grief for what is happening around them.

Sunny · 12 July 2014 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

I used up a lot of Kleenex on this chapter - but those were happy tears, I promise! I did not follow this story from the beginning, I glanced at the chapters from time to time, but I did not get hooked until I had about half the chapters available. Finarfin really hd a sucky life, most of the time, didn't he? His early life was dominated by his eldest brother, who had only scorn for his younger siblings, and his father reserved most of his affection for his remarkable eldest son. And after the Rebellion he was stuck with the Noldorin Crown, and having to repair and heal both his own shattered clan, but also dealing with all the mess the Rebellion had left in the relationships with the other clans. And then he had to go to war - as a commander, no less, having to send people to their deathe. No wonder he needed a bit of a "holiday" for a while. I was relieved when Eärwen forgave him what had happened with Faroniel, and I am certain she is going to make sure that the younger Aikanáro stays a part of the family. Because she knows her husband does need him in order to be happy. And she WILL have a happy husband and a complete family, and if her children and other family have any sense, they will cooperate. Or else. ;-) I'm not sure that Valinor is quite prepared for the concept of a Bastard Prince. So I guess that at least for now the relationship may stay at least somewhat unofficial. But I guess the other Kings at least need to be told (and it might be interesting to be a fly on the wall for those discussions!) OK, I'm off to start reading the story from the beginning again! :-)

Author's reply

I am glad the tears were happy ones :-) I am surprised myself that it took as long as it did for Finarfin to crash as he did. He had an awful lot on him for so many years. I know Valinor is not ready for a bastard prince. I might need to write that conversation with the kings finding out about him. That would need to be added to a segment with Galadriel finding out as another reader requested. I will see what I can do, if I can get the muse working on that. This summer has been too difficult for me to do any writing so far. Thank you so very much for the feedback. I hope you enjoyed the reread!

White Queen · 10 July 2014 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

Wow. I cannot believe this is over. I've been following the story for the last few months, and found myself admiring you more and more. The effort you put into it is quite clear, and the characterizations and motivations were wonderfully written. Thank you for sharing it!

Author's reply

Thank you so very much for sticking with this story as it unfolded. I am pleased that you enjoyed it. thank you so very much for reading and enjoying! I appreciate you letting me know.

jgmsccc · 10 July 2014 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

Hi. I am sorry that I have not been reviewing as this story went along. As I am not a writer, I don't always know what to say. I did enjoy the story. It kept me fascinated as to how you would resolve all the issues you kept creating. I am intrigued about the Amanian's side of the Numenorian revolt. Maybe another story???

Author's reply

I am delighted that you kept with the story. I appreciate you taking the time to leave me a few lines now :-) I will have to see what the muse tells me next as far as a story about the Amanian side of the Numenorean revolt. I have started another story, but it has nothing to do with Numenoreans. Given my abysmal track record for multi-chapter stories for the last six years, it will take me a while to get this new story written. I will see if the muse prompts me with your suggestion. Thank you so very much for reading and enjoying as you did!

Larner · 10 July 2014 · Chapter 20: Chapter 20

I rejoice that healing at last came in this manner. I grieve for the years lost to them, but am so glad that at last Aicanaro has been brought into the family. And I'd love to know what Artanis Galadriel thought of this change once she returned to the Undying Lands! (Hint, hint!)

Author's reply

Three thousand years is a long time to wonder and mourn, but at least they were reunited at last. I admit I have not considered what Galadriel might think of this situation. I might explore this at some point and add it to the end of the story. Thank you for asking about it! This summer has been too difficult for any writing at all, but maybe once I get things sorted once again, I can write Galadriel's meeting with the new family. She does not know she has a younger sister in Valinor either... I am grateful for your comments and reviews for each chapter. Thanks for taking the time to read and enjoy!

Larner · 5 July 2014 · Chapter 19: Chapter 19

Oh, but these three do have such excellent reason to appreciate just how heinous this invasion is as kinsmen, no matter how distantly as seen by those threatening Aman. I rejoice that he has found his second son Aicanaro and has found him worthy. That Aule himself should train him is so appropriate! And Arafinwe has reason to be proud of both his peredhil children, if not his daughter's more distant descendants.

Author's reply

I thought it only fitting that none of these three should have to mourn this horrible travesty alone. Now that Arafinwe is not alone in his knowledge of what he has done, I think he will be a bit more at peace to have a kindred spirit at hand. Finding his son was a great blessing indeed. They both needed this. Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!

Larner · 4 July 2014 · Chapter 18: Chapter 18

Oh, but a wonderful return to the relationship they have known and must know, and excellent growth in each of them. Falmamire sounds delightful, and so wonderful to learn that her mortal sister has come to such an estate. Alas that he cannot reveal himself to Andreth, though. And in time he may learn the fate of Aicanaro as well.

Author's reply

Arafinwe and Earwen both needed the healing in order for each of them to go on. Their people need them to be king and queen and they really do need each other even though both had resigned earlier to go it alone. Their newest addition is a healing balm to them both. Even though he cannot let Andreth know about himself, he at least will know her fate and fates of her descendants. Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!

Siiw · 3 July 2014 · Chapter 19: Chapter 19

I can't believe that this story doesn't have 20 reviews pr.chapter. It is simply one of the best stories I have read on this site. I got worried when this wasn't posted at the usual time! Several of the last few chapters have been so heartbreaking that I simply didn't know what to say. I had to stop reading this at work, because it made me cry. This chapter, however, made me smile. I really like your Arafinwë. He has made a good character in your other stories, but here he really shines. I'll try to post a comment on every chapter later when the story is finished, when I just find the right words!

Author's reply

I am flattered by your compliments. Thank you!!! I was surprised that there are so few reviewers but that does seem to be the way of it nowadays in the fanfiction world. I am pleased to know that you are enjoying my story, even if it has been heartbreaking. This story was about six years in the making and has been a very difficult tale to tell. I look forward to hearing your comments on the different chapters when you are so inclined to put down a few words. Thank you so very much for letting me know you are enjoying this tale!

Fiondil · 29 June 2014 · Chapter 18: Chapter 18

Well, I'm glad to see that Eärwen was willing to forgive him and they were able to start over. And he learns of his peredhel daughter's fate at least. First Queen of Númenor! That makes sense, given her bloodline. Eru does indeed draw straight with crooked lines. Falmamírë is cute with all her running and explaining why she was running and everyone telling her not to. And Arafinwë's quip to Eärwen that she is definitely Eärwen's daughter and Eärwen's quip back. Too funny.

Author's reply

Yes, Eru does indeed! The reconciliation definitely will help Arafiwne go on again and having the little girl around will be a blessing to both Earwen and Arafinwe. I think the elder children will be surprised when they are reborn or return home to Valinor and find out they have a younger sibling. It makes me wonder just how many reborns came back to find new siblings running around. Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!

ellon · 26 June 2014 · Chapter 18: Chapter 18

I loved this story. At first I wasn't sure if I was going to like this take on Arafinwe's history but by the end of it I found myself really enjoying the idea of him finding healing... still a little difficult to swallow but the journey through Mandos and exploring the concept of Arafinwe's self discovery as king and an ellon was intriguing. Overall I enjoyed it!

Author's reply

I am pleased that you have enjoyed this story so far. Thanks for taking the plunge and reading it :-) There are still two more chapters to go, and I hope you like them as well. Thank you so very much for reading, enjoying, and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!

Fiondil · 22 June 2014 · Chapter 17: Chapter 17

Arafinwë certainly got an earful from the villagers. Loved the whole incident with the baker. That was too precious. And his guards. Poor ellyn having people disrespect them because they made the hard choice to remain behind to help protect the Queen while their fellows went off to fight, and most likely to die. It couldn't have been an easy decision on their part. I'm glad Arafinwë showed them that they were worthy and should not be ashamed of their decisions. And now Eärwen shows up out of the blue! This should be an interesting conversation. ;-)

Author's reply

I am sure those villagers had quite a bit to tell him. I don't think he was ready to hear such things though before he went away to the war. He definitely returned a changed ellon. I really like the baker. She was fun. this excursion out to the villages raised Arafinwe in the esteem of his people and his guards and I know that neither group expected such a thing of their king. Yes, the conversation with Earwen will indeed be interesting... Thanks for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!