A well needed visit to those who needed to know he DOES understand, and who need to know he lives his words and work.
As for Earwen awaiting him in his sitting room--that IS a (hopefully) heartening surprise!
Author's reply
He has a far greater understanding of his subjects now than he ever had before and he has a great empathy with them which it seemed he previously lacked. I think his experiences will make him a better king.
As for Earwen being there, that certainly is a surprise for him! we will have to wait until next week to see what kind of a surprise it is for him.
You know, I have wondered if he will clean up the mess he made or if he will make the servants do it.
Author Reply: I got interrupted by the dogs needing to be let outside and forgot to thank you for reading and reviewing, so, thank you!
Fiondil
· 17 June 2014
· Chapter 16: Chapter 16
Eärwen is royally pissed and rightly so. She will not easily forgive him for what he's done, but I really feel sorry for Arafinwë. He's really caught between a rock and a hard place and that's a terrible place for anyone to be in. I can sympathize with his wondering why Eönwë hadn't let him die. It would have been easier, but not necessarily right for any of them.
Author's reply
Earwen is extremely angry and he is extremely hurt. Even if it seems that it might have been more merciful if Eonwe had let him die, it would have been worse for everyone else in the long run. He does not see this now, but perhaps he will come to see it in time.
Thanks for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Twoflower2
· 13 June 2014
· Chapter 16: Chapter 16
A totally believable reaction from Earwen. Had she understood and forgiven right there on the spot, it would have been totally unnatural. With time she might, hopefully :)
One thing I am wondering about - is Arafinwe ever to meet his descendants for ex. in Numenor.
Thank you for continuing this story, Ellie.
Author's reply
There is no way she could have forgiven him on the spot for what he has done. It remains to be seen what she will do later, if she chooses to do anything further at all. A place by the sea is she has always wanted. Without King Arafinwe, she can have it. Part of Arafinwe's punishment was that he would never again see his children in Middle-Earth. Very slowly he will and has come to accept this no matter how much it hurts.
Larner
· 11 June 2014
· Chapter 16: Chapter 16
Excellent advice he receives from the High King, and I so pray he takes it--and that she accepts it, too. Earwen has much to forgive, but must to understand as well.
Author's reply
We will have to see how well Arafinwe takes advice about how he could continue his own healing. He tried to see to the healing of others who returned, but it didn't go as he had planned as we saw in that meeting with the other kings. Arafinwe also did what he could to explain things to Earwen, but what she does with this information when she cools down remains to be seen. He believes she will hate him forever and he believes she should react that way. At some point they both will have to go one with their lives - whether together or apart.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
galathil
· 11 June 2014
· Chapter 15: Chapter 15
Hi Ellie, I am catching up with your wonderful story. Just letting you know that I am still around and loving Forging Hope. Had to read the whole story, as somehow I missed it. Don't how that happened? I know our king is sad but I think in the end all is going to be ok. Then Ellie I never know, what you are going to through up in your stories. Really can't wait for the next chapter. LOL
Gaalthil
Author's reply
Hey Galathil!
It is good to hear from you again! I'm so very pleased you are enjoying this story. I had always wanted to read a Finarfin love story of the ilk so many other characters get, but I never could find one, so I wrote one myself :-) It took forever (okay 6 years or so) to write this story, so I am glad you are enjoying it. You will have to keep reading to see how things for for Finarfin, I do admit that the chapter I posted today is not a good one for him. Poor guy!
Thanks so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
I think there is a setting you can select to receive email notification of new stories that I (or any other author) post.
Fiondil
· 7 June 2014
· Chapter 15: Chapter 15
Those who remain behind really have no clue what those who went to war suffered and will still suffer for some time after. But I think that is true to life anyway and Elves are no different from us Mortals in that regard. Ingwë's reservations about the Númenóreans is prophetic, but obviously his view did not hold sway since we know that some Elves did trade with the Edain. Still, I suspect he will say "I told you so" when the time comes. A lot of emotions being displayed in this chapter and the tensions and prejudices of the various groups is admirably delineated by your deft hand, Ellie. Good chapter.
Typo alert: "aide" should be "aid".
Author's reply
Those who stayed behind are definitely clueless just as those who went away do not fully understand the hardship experienced by those who left. No one listened to Ingwe in regards to Numenor ad it will come back to bite them. But 3000 years is a long time to wait to find out that you were wrong... Thank you for the compliment on handling the emotions, tension, and prejudices. It had to be tough coming back and having to deal with all of that.
Thanks for the typo alert :-)
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I really appreciate it!
Larner
· 3 June 2014
· Chapter 15: Chapter 15
He still has his confession to make to his wife, and her forgiveness to know. I wonder if his children will come to Numenor?
Author's reply
He does still need to talk to his wife and it is eating away at him. He will talk to her soon enough.
Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Troy
· 3 June 2014
· Chapter 15: Chapter 15
I was a bit curious as to how Eärwen would fit in to this whole... Situation, but it seems everything works out. Kinda. Maybe not. Of course Arafinwë is right, but so are Ingwë and his wife. Time changes things... A lot. It makes me wonder how this Arafinwë reacts when Ar-Pharazon gets all greedy. Oddly enough I feel more sympathetic for Ingwë. Not that I don't feel the same for Arafinwë but it is easier when everything is black and white. One land evil, one land good. One race evil, one good. Damn the gray-ness of the world.
Author's reply
Few things are black and white - even in Tolkien's world, and I agree it is extremely frustrating. For the moment, all three kings are correct in their assessment of Numenor. Ingwë is the only one who has guessed that Numenor, which has yet to be established, might be a time bomb. As for Eärwen ... well, we will just have to see in which direction that ball bounces.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Fiondil
· 29 May 2014
· Chapter 14: Chapter 14
This is my favorite chapter to date. The meeting with Finwë was unexpected, but I'm glad they were able to speak with one another and come to some understanding. And Námo just rocks. LOL!
The meeting with Aicanáro was bittersweet as well. It's unfortunate that Arafinwë's bond with his children has been severed, but I think Eönwë has the right of it. It's good to see Arafinwë as the king he is rather than as the rather lost Laurehér.
Author's reply
I wrote this chapter long before I ever managed to get Arafinwe "killed off" in battle. I knew that this time of healing would be necessary and how it would affect all parties involved. It is one of my favorite chapters as well.
Eonwe rocks, but he is grim as well in the duties he is called upon to perform. It must hurt him to have to do such things as he did here, even if he never shows the pain of tough love.
Arafinwe is king and behaving as such once again. Unfortunately or fortunately, I really don't know which, he is all too familiar with the roll of hiding his pain and going on.
Thanks so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much1
Larner
· 28 May 2014
· Chapter 14: Chapter 14
A heavy cost, to lose that bond with his children in such a manner. But at least two other relationships have been rekindled in a healthy manner, though those two should be dead.
Author's reply
The Halls of Mandos are a place of healing and some spirits do take longer to heal than others. The healing that Finarfin received there went both ways in each instance for his father and his son were both in need of healing as well. It was unfair but justifiable that the bond with the children was lost - just another casualty of this war with Morgoth, I suppose. It is sad though.
Thank you very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Twoflower2
· 21 May 2014
· Chapter 13: Chapter 13
Now I see that my review repeats the previous review word for word! Sorry, this was completely unintentional. But this is probably a right moment to say that I am tempted to write the very same review after almost every chapter: "oh no, not this, I wonder what happens next". But it might get somewhat repetitive :) so I only do it once in a while.
Author's reply
Don't worry that your review repeated another's review. I think it is amusing. At least I know that readers are thinking alike! I want my readers wondering what will happen next and it is perfectly fine to keep saying "oh no, not this, I wonder what happens next". I am happy for any feedback at all. :-)
Thanks for reading and telling me your thoughts even when they echo those of others. LOL! I hope the next chapter gives you some answers.
Twoflower2
· 21 May 2014
· Chapter 13: Chapter 13
Oh, no! What could have happened with Faroniel? Was it Belegon, perhaps? Poor Finarfin just can't get a break.
Author's reply
Finarfin feared she would get sick again after he saw her fall ill before...
Lindelea
· 21 May 2014
· Chapter 13: Chapter 13
Oh no! What could have happened?
Earlier, Laureher's leadership shone through in the courage and loyalty he inspired in his fellow villagers.
I kept wondering what would happen when he put on his helm -- who would recognise him there on the battlefield. What would they think -- that he had returned from the dead, perhaps? Sent by the Valar to sustain the army, bring new hope? Only to be cruelly cut down...
Aicanáro was heartbreakingly sweet in his offer to go and fight so that his father didn't have to.
The parting was well done, both his wife's acknowledging his duty, as well as expressing honestly her satisfaction at his pain in the parting, that it might bring him home to them sooner.
And then, of course, her death. Only a little mitigated by the fact that the children seem to remain well, if anguished, and other villagers are around them? I think I got that right. Which means, perhaps, that it's not an Orc attack as I first assumed.
Interesting that the Maia have orders not to let him go.
Author's reply
Laureher is a fine leader even when he doesn't mean to be one. His son loves him dearly and wants to be big and strong and a protector just like his dad. Unfortunately the little guy is in a tough position now with Faroniel gone.
I'm glad the parting with Faroniel and the family worked for you. She had done this before and understood full well what the consequences could be for her in the end. I don't think she ever imagined she would be the one to die while he was away at the war.
He had feared she would get sick again some day and was over-protective of her in previous chapters. I don't think it ever occurred to him that such a thing could happen to her while he was away. The last time he swished his family good night she seems weak and farther away than normal. She was already dying then, but he just did not understand it.
He is too important to the army, more so than he realizes. You will learn more next chapter.
Thanks for the long review! I appreciate it very much!
Fiondil
· 21 May 2014
· Chapter 13: Chapter 13
Arafinwë is very good with Damrod and Barandir, especially looking out for Damrod and helping him through his first battle, but the ending is quite intense. Let's hope the poor ellon makes it through the night. Right now with Faroniel dead he probably doesn't want to live any longer. Love Eönwë here even if we only 'see' him from Arafinwë's perspective before he passes out.
Author's reply
I rather liked the bit with Damrod and Barandir. Laureher needed good friends such as those two to get him through the march to join the army. It is safe to say that Eonwe is his only hope at this point. He has none of his own left to him and he is in rather bad shape physically at this point. Yikes!
Thanks for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it :-)
Larner
· 20 May 2014
· Chapter 13: Chapter 13
What could have taken Faroniel in that manner? No wonder he wishes to lie down and die! At least he has friends who will not only protect him but see him healed so that he can return to his Elven wife. As for the children...well we shall see what we shall see regarding them, at least.
Author's reply
Faroniel had gotten sick before and it was a constant fear of Laureher's that she would get sick. He is fortunate to have friends and Maiar to come to his aid. You will just have to wait and see as he will what becomes of the children. The poor guy just can't get a break, can he?
Thanks for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Fiondil
· 20 May 2014
· Chapter 12: Chapter 12
Those recruiters are pretty smarmy. Loved Angadan's reaction when he figures out that Laurehér is actually Arafinwë, King of the Noldor. Too funny. Arafinwë has a difficult decision to make, though. Not telling his wife the truth may keep her and the children safe, but it has to be a wrench for him to dissimulate before her and pretend all is well when it isn't. And he was so happy, too. Probably happier than he's ever been. Too bad.
Author's reply
The recruiters are smarmy, but that most likely was the way of it at that time. Angadan is one of my favorite OCs. I really like the way he turned out.
It is a pity that Finarfin's happiness always seems to be compromised. He really can't get a break. He is far stronger than he realizes though to survive what he has and what he has yet to endure.
Thanks so very much for reading and reviewing. I am most appreciative.
Lindelea
· 14 May 2014
· Chapter 12: Chapter 12
How heartbreaking! His love for his family is so clear. How will he ever explain his decision, without looking like a total cad for abandoning them, even as he tries to protect them?
Author's reply
There is no easy way out of this for him. No matter what he does or says he will suffer for it even if he is doing this for all the right reasons.
Thanks for reading and reviewing! I do appreciate it very much!
Larner
· 14 May 2014
· Chapter 12: Chapter 12
At least he is able to see the needs of all and to prepare for them as best he can. And he leaves his mortal wife and children in excellent hands. He is right--he must return now to his proper place with the army.
Author's reply
Arafinwe is described as being the wisest son of Finwe. Even if he did not act wisely, as a knowledgeable outsider might see, early on in the story, he is being wise again now. He does not seem to be able to win no matter what he does. At least he isn't trapped in the village with no news of his army and no way to return to them now that he knows he is king and knows what is the right thing for him to do by his people. I think would have been far worse for him.
Thanks for reading and reviewing. I do greatly appreciate it.
Fiondil
· 10 May 2014
· Chapter 11: Chapter 11
It was interesting to see the different reactions to the children, the mortals exclaiming on their beauty and precociousness and Arafinwë thinking that they seemed to be developing rather normally for elven children and why was everyone making such a fuss? *grin*
Belegon may have apologized but Arafinwë's wise not to trust him and further than he can throw the man and maybe not even that far.
Recruiters. Ack! Last thing any of them need. But the sword speaking to Arafinwë... that was something. His realization that he was the king of the Noldor, though, that really had to have come as a shock. No wonder he fell to his knees. It's one thing to believe yourself a noble and a captain, it's something else entirely to *know* that you're the king and THE Captain. That's going to take some getting used to.
Author's reply
I think those kids much have been amazing to see and fun to watch. As for Belegon, he was never one to be trusted. I remember years ago, writing the scene where he first showed up and I knew he was going to be trouble.
On the behavior of the recruiters, I don't remember if I told you that I had in mind the song "Twa Recruitin' Sergeants" as sung by Alex Beaton ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FtpyUFpZg-g ) as well as the "Sharp's Rifles" movie where Richard Sharp meets recruiters while posing as a potential new recruit in a village and sees first hand how they entice poor men to go to war. I think I captured the recruiters well enough in this story.
We will see how well Arafinwe copes with his realization of who and what he really is and the responsibilities that entails.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Fantasia
· 9 May 2014
· Chapter 11: Chapter 11
I would recommend Laurehér to take his family and move, get away from the village. But where can he go? he can't show up to his people with a new wife and kids, he has a wife and at least one daughter alive. He is in a big trouble and better for him to maintain a low, very low profile.
I'm assuming that his kids are mortal, but they should have a bigger part in Middle Earth destiny, if only because his inheritance....It is complicated, but the Valars knew and they blessed this union in a way...something good must come from this, beside the twins, they are a blessing by themselves no matter what.
Author's reply
Laurehér is very limited in his options at this point. This is very much of a no win situation for him. It remains to be seen what good may come from all that Arafinwe has done and the definition of "good" is very much open to interpretation.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Larner
· 7 May 2014
· Chapter 11: Chapter 11
I can appreciate just how the sword must have stirred much in his muddled memories. And now--to KNOW what he had been--that must be quite the shock indeed! How will this knowledge change his place within the village?
Author's reply
I think it was hard for him to have a such a taste of home as he found in the memories brought forth by the sword and not long for more things of elven make. that final realization I know he did not see coming. If he feared the villagers reaction to finding out he is a lord, then what could possibly lie in wait for him in finding out just how highborn he truly is? That should be of great concern to him, if he is wise.
Thank you for reading and reviewing! I do appreciate it greatly.
Fiondil
· 4 May 2014
· Chapter 10: Chapter 10
It was good to see Yavanna helping out. Maybe the Valar might not approve of what has happened but neither do they condemn it or Arafinwë for what he has done. The Song of Power was awesome. Loved the little ceremony of Arafinwë introducing his children to Eru and the Valar. I'm sure they were tickled pink with the Valier cooing and sighing over the babes while the Valar congratulated one another and passed out cigars. LOL! And now to see how Arafinwë handles twin terrors, as they are likely to become once they pass the cute-as-a-button stage.
Author's reply
Arafinwë has to get a break at some point - even if just for a little while. I think the Valar love and prize all life, so I believe they would have delighted in his children, too. We'll have to wait and see what the children put him through later in life.
Thank you so very much for reading and reviewing. I appreciate it very much!
Larner
· 1 May 2014
· Chapter 10: Chapter 10
I rejoice that the Valar watch over him and are glad of how she fulfills his needs. The babies sound beautiful, and the visions fascinating.
Author's reply
Arafinwe deserved some good things happening to him. He is blessed to have Faroniel and the children as he does. He was considered the fairest of the sons of Finwe so it stands to reason that he would have beautiful children, too :-)
Thank you for reading and reviewing! I appreciate it very much!
Monalex
· 30 April 2014
· Chapter 8: Chapter 8
Hello Ellie,
Thanks for answering my last review! I have been looking into your comments, but I can't seem to think of someone other than Finwe who took another wife and that under special circumstances... could you please tell me who else did the same as you have Arafinwe doing?
Also your right it would be way worse if Arafinwe knew he was cheating on his wife, who is waiting for him in the Blessed Realm. It does lessen the sting a little knowing he didn't know the circumstances of their parting. So yes he acted with the knowledge he has at the moment, though he will be happy in the future with his "other" wife, I think he will feel awful for Earwen's sake and himself when he does remember that HE, was the one who left his wife to go fight a war, thus leaving her in charge of his kingdom. He's put him self between a sword and a hard wall, so to speak. On the other hand, if your going to have him having children, it does beg the question: will they be granted the same choice of Elrond and Elros at the end of the War of Wrath?
Finally it would be interesting that after you finish this story, you start a new one about his return to Valinor and his rekindling the relationship he had with his wife - adding of course all the problems they have along the way - who I'm sure is actually the love of his life. Although will you have them being together again?
From the chapters I read, I get the feeling that him and Faroniel are only looking for companionship. I'm not discounting any feelings they may have for each other, but I don't think they are the ultimate love of each other... for Faroniel at least it was her first husband.
Cheers!
Monalex
Monalex
· 30 April 2014
· Chapter 8: Chapter 8
Hello Ellie,
Thanks for answering my last review! I have been looking into your comments, but I can't seem to think of someone other than Finwe who took another wife and that under special circumstances... could you please tell me who else did the same as you have Arafinwe doing?
Also your right it would be way worse if Arafinwe knew he was cheating on his wife, who is waiting for him in the Blessed Realm. It does lessen the sting a little knowing he didn't know the circumstances of their parting. So yes he acted with the knowledge he has at the moment, though he will be happy in the future with his "other" wife, I think he will feel awful for Earwen's sake and himself when he does remember that HE, was the one who left his wife to go fight a war, thus leaving her in charge of his kingdom. He's put him self between a sword and a hard wall, so to speak. On the other hand, if your going to have him having children, it does beg the question: will they be granted the same choice of Elrond and Elros at the end of the War of Wrath?
Finally it would be interesting that after you finish this story, you start a new one about his return to Valinor and his rekindling the relationship he had with his wife - adding of course all the problems they have along the way - who I'm sure is actually the love of his life. Although will you have them being together again?
From the chapters I read, I get the feeling that him and Faroniel are only looking for companionship. I'm not discounting any feelings they may have for each other, but I don't think they are the ultimate love of each other... for Faroniel at least it was her first husband.
Cheers!
Monalex
Author's reply
Tolkien said that remarriage among elves was rare, but that it did happen though it was discouraged given what happened with Finwe and Miriel. He did not cite the names of the other elves who remarried though as they were not important to the tales told in The Silmarillion or later histories.
My story should answer at least some of your questions as it goes along. Let me know if by the end of the story you feel I did not answer anything, and I will see what I can do to get you an answer :-)
Thanks for replying and discussing!