|About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search|
|A Long Walk Down a Short Pier by Grey Wonderer||15 Review(s)|
|Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 3/29/2014|
|Read and enjoyed this. Just thought I'd review. You do have a couple spelling errors though.|
|GamgeeFest||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 12/6/2009|
|*giggles* Pippin may have been mistaken about the boating, but he's got the flattery down pat!|
Incident with the sheep costume? :)
Author Reply: Yes, Pippin is very charming, isn't he?
The incident with the sheep costume is from "Merry had a Little Lamb". It's an older fiction of mine.
|Baggins Babe||Reviewed Chapter: Prologue on 11/3/2009|
|I know where he'd like to put them but I don't think there's room in there and I'm not sure we could hold Mr. Merry down long enough to finish the job," Sam muttered. |
*snort* *gurgle* *gasp*
Merry does know exactly how to push Frodo's buttons, doesn't he? And trust Sam to make an observation like this!
As for Sheep Month in the Tooklands...........!!!
Author Reply: Oh, I am so glad you enjoyed this. For some reason, I could just hear Sam saying that. hehehe
And Sheep Month just sounds like a Tookland event to me. (I secretly want a sheep month anyone.)
|Baggins Babe||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 11/3/2009|
|“Sounds that way,” Saradoc nodded. “I feel especially singled out since you and I are now drifting aimlessly in a boat.” |
I have always liked Saradoc and this remark just makes me love him more - priceless!
Loved this, GW. Diamond's horror upon learning that Pip can swim, Merry's indignation that Pip has taken his boat......... And of course Diamond knows how to hook a future Thain.
Author Reply: Saradoc is one of my favorite characters for some reason. I am constantly putting him into my stories.
Thank you for the lovely review and I am very glad that you enjoyed it.
|Larner||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 10/29/2009|
|Ah, yes--she knows what she's after, and has hooked it firmly! Delightful! And Merry certainly appreciates Tooks in some ways better than Pippin does!|
Thanks for a wonderful giggle!
Author Reply: You are most welcome. I'm very glad you enjoyed it. I do think Merry has a special insight into Tooks thanks to his Mother and Pippin. hehehe
|Larner||Reviewed Chapter: Prologue on 10/29/2009|
|Ah, but trust Merry to see the illogic of it for Hobbiton and the Shire! And love Frodo's temper tamtrum!|
Author Reply: Merry was thinking this one over entirely too much. He needed to enjoy it, or maybe he enjoyed picking on Frodo a bit here. In any case I figure Frodo will celebrate anyway just as soon as he calms down. LOL
|Andrea||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 10/28/2009|
|"Now, I’m going back to Brandy Hall and try to forget that you can swim."|
Awww! That's true love ;-)
Great story! I especially enjoyed Merry's and Saradoc's commentary!
Author Reply: Thank you. I suspect that as a Took and someone not comfortable around water, Diamond was better off not thinking about Pippin swimming. LOL It really must be true love.
I always enjoy writing Saradoc so it was fun to have him and Merry commenting on Pippin's situation. I'm glad you enjoyed it.
|Andrea||Reviewed Chapter: Prologue on 10/28/2009|
|Sheep Month? They'd love that one in the Tooklands.|
LOL!!! Although Merry can sometimes be really annoying with his logical thinking, his arguments are still highly comical :-)
Sheep Month - what a splendid idea!
Author Reply: I know! There really should be a Sheep Month! I'm glad you agree. LOL
Thanks for reading and laughing.
|mews1945||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 10/28/2009|
|Thoroughly enjoyable. I love Merry and Saradoc's observations on Tooks and courting and lasses. And Diamond certainly knows how to handle her hobbit. |
Author Reply: Thank you. I think Diamond will always have the upper hand in that relationship. : )
|Dreamflower||Reviewed Chapter: 1 on 10/28/2009|
|LOLOLOLOLOLOL! *howl*guffaw*giggle*chortle*chuckle*snort*wipes eyes!*|
OK, this was just too funny! I loved the way you intertwined the two conversations-- but my favorite part was the reactions to Pippin's revelation that he could swim! That was a hoot! And Merry and Saradoc's running commentary the whole time...
Great story, GW! I love your Pippin and Diamond.
Author Reply: Thank you. I love the way you review with sound-words. It makes me feel like someone is in the room laughing. Then again, maybe I'm just hearing things. hehehe
I had fun letting Saradoc and Merry do the commentary as if it were a sporting event and I always enjoy writing Saradoc.
For some reason, I have always thought that if Pippin really could swim, it would be a source of some scandal among the Tooks since most hobbits were not very fond of the water. I could imagine Paladin trying to keep the topic from coming up and I could also see Diamond being completely shocked by it.
Glad you enjoyed this one and thanks so much for the lovely review!