Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search

Elf Academy 4 - The Unfinished Tales  by Fiondil 11 Review(s)
ArasindaReviewed Chapter: 59 on 11/29/2017
Dearest Beta Sisters for Fiondil,

I have missed your work on his behalf. Some fans have become dishearted and said good-bye, but there are many of us who are still waiting for the closing chapters. I believe many of us would be satisfied with even the finishing outlines to Fiondil's work other than stay in limbo. Closure with the last "adventure" for the elves in modern times feels needed. However, I do have a suggestion. If possible see if TolkienScribe can assist. Fiondil enjoyed his work, and he has written of Elves in our time and dealing with the Dagor Dagorath. I miss Fiondil's creative imagination within the world of Tolkien. It was a wonderful sandbox at the end of a busy day or week. Elessar, have hope.


KathyGReviewed Chapter: 59 on 7/14/2017
Ouch, sorry to hear that! Recovering from surgery's no fun, I know, especially when you have to endure pain in the process. Please tell Shemyazza she's got our best wishes!

Will the next four chapters finish the story, then, or will it have to remain in a state of permanent hiatus once the fourth and last chapter has been posted?

KathyGReviewed Chapter: 59 on 7/14/2017
You've come to the final chapter that can be posted, haven't you? The story cannot be finished, and that's a real shame. Well, we all thank for for all of the chapters that you were able to post for us. At least we got to see how part of the story goes. If only Fiondil could have lived long enough to finish it!

Author Reply: I think that actually there are 4 more chapters. Shemyazza has them, but she is recovering from a painful, long-awaited surgery for the next several weeks.


Kaylee ArafinwielReviewed Chapter: 59 on 6/5/2017
Dear Ellie, Shemyaza and Mari,

I've had a lot of family stuff going on these days and I know you have too, off and on, everyone has RL difficulties. I hope all's well with you all now or as much as it can be. The world is quiet here, for now.

We all greatly miss our Fiondil, and if there's anything I can do to help with this story I'm here.

If this is truly to remain my heart-Atto's Unfinished Tales, I understand, and I want you three Beta Amigas to know I love and respect you for getting as far as you did with it. I hope we'll remain in contact and you won't just fade away, you, me and our fellow Fiondilie.


Kaylee Arafinwiel,

yelde indonyo to Atto Fiondil

Author Reply: Thank you very much for the offer of assistance. Shemyaza is recovering from surgery right now, and we haven't discussed anything related to the story for a long time due to extenuating circumstances on both of our parts.


KathyGReviewed Chapter: 59 on 6/1/2017
It's been almost 2 months since you've lasted posted a chapter. I take it, then, that this is as far as you'll be able to continue the story?

NinqReviewed Chapter: 59 on 4/10/2017
If Glorfindel is perfectly capable of flying the plane on his own, and Alex already owned the plane, then why was Rufus needed at all in the first place? Might be he's one of the pieces of the puzzle that needs to fall into place, but somehow that sounds ridiculous... time will hopefully tell, but I'd be happy enough to know Redelfs background before we run out of the chapters written by Fiondil

gwedReviewed Chapter: 59 on 4/7/2017
Oh I can't wait to find out Rufus' reaction to the so-called Little People. lol Like all the humans before him, it's bound to be good.

I don't know why, but I got ridiculously excited to find out Glorfindel's a pilot. I love it. My reaction was the same as Alex's. I'm just waiting for some human to finally yell at him "what in the blazes else can you do?" Aside from looking gorgeous which does come naturally! Rufus' response to him and Gwyn being top of the top ladies' men was gold.

Though talking about wincing in sympathy for Rufus. A person looking like death warmed over should really be made into a poster for Namo's little chats. You don't even have to ask. Just look at the person and if they look like the poster then you know.

I'm one of the very few people apparently who doesn't like Alex, but I gotta admit that I enjoyed him in this chap. For one, his responses are always funny when someone rides him about having a girlfriend. Welcome to the real world of relationships and the teasing that comes with it!

Must've been tricky to feign nonchalance at Glorfindel's Ireland story when Alex realized what he was doing. It's moments like those where I really love looking at the Elves through human eyes.

obsidianjReviewed Chapter: 59 on 4/6/2017
Uh, oh... every time someone says something like "What could go wrong?" It goes wrong. Let's just hope it doesn't go too badly for our guys. I kind of like Rufus. He might be sleazy, but I can't decide if he can't be redeemed or if he will turn into a bad guy for our heroes.

Artelemnar FŽanestarReviewed Chapter: 59 on 4/6/2017
WOW, I want a lock like that on my bike XD I can just about imagine myself singing The Eldar, by Blind Guardian every time I need my bike to go to school

Glorfindel being able to fly a plane should not have surprised me.

Alex feeling uneasy worries me... He wouldn't feel like that for no reason...

I really love that Coleman's actually exists. The attention to detail in Fiondil's stories is incredible.

Thank you for sharing yet another great chapter with us :)

LarnerReviewed Chapter: 59 on 4/5/2017
And were the little people he saw Hobbits, I wonders? Heh!

Sounds as if Colemans would be a perfect place to visit--but not at the height of summer with the humidity high!

First Page | Previous Page | Next Page | Last Page

Return to Chapter List