Stories of Arda Home Page
About Us News Resources Login Become a member Help Search

Elf Academy 4 - The Unfinished Tales  by Fiondil 531 Review(s)
GwedReviewed Chapter: 58 on 3/29/2017
I can imagine I speak for everyone when I say I don't know if there are enough words to express how much I appreciate your decision to try and complete this story. Because wow. And thank you. I was just going to beg you, in the event you elected not to, that perhaps you could just release Fiondil's notes to the public instead so that we might have some idea what was supposed to happen or how it was supposed to end.

That said, really, thank you. I don't envy you the task. While it's almost like just how we try to get in Tolkien's mind when writing fanfiction, Fiondil's imagination is quite the undertaking. :) But I can't think of anyone who can write his characters as closely as he did than you two, especially Glorfindel. I'll admit, I can't wait for the story to focus on him again and was so saddened to find out it wouldn't be the case (when you announced we were coming to the end of the written chapters). Now I'm certainly smiling again.

Thank you for doing this for us and for him. Really can't tell you how much it means.

Artelemnar FŽanestarReviewed Chapter: 58 on 3/28/2017
Uh oh, I have a bad feeling about this...
I do hope nothing bad happens on the way, but this just can't not go wrong.
I'm really worried for Alex, is going to be allright?
I kind of want to know who Louise is now and I almost feel sorry for Rufus, he's going to have nightmares about that "chat" for the rest of his life.
Great chapter, as always :)

TariReviewed Chapter: 57 on 3/28/2017
I do hope you finish this story. You all know Fiondil's way of thinking and would do an excellent job. Of that I am very sure.

jgmscccReviewed Chapter: 58 on 3/27/2017
Thank you so much for taking on the completion of this story. I so enjoy "being with" these characters and look forward to continuing to read about them

kathareinReviewed Chapter: 58 on 3/27/2017
Not a review exactly - just adding my thanks. Youall have done such a splendid job especially considering some of the RL stuff you are dealing with. Carry on if you can, as and when and if you will. If it becomes undoable, I am still most grateful.

UTfrogReviewed Chapter: 58 on 3/27/2017
Hooray for the news that you are planning to finish the story. I know it will be excellent. I enjoyed this chapter. I would have loved hearing Namo's speech with both Sanderson and Rufus. Thank you.

Cleo05Reviewed Chapter: 58 on 3/27/2017
It's great news that you will countinue the story. Thank you so much for that! You are doing a wonderful job. Is there anything we could do to help you? Like proof reading, research, ... ? I would be very willing to help you and I am sure some others here would be as well.

6336Reviewed Chapter: 57 on 3/24/2017
If this story ends here then the Cliffe King strikes again!

I hope you are able to continue Arthurs work, if only so that a lot of people do not go bald from frustrated hair pulling!

Artelemnar, organic browsers are only so good, they can sometimes drop information like a non-organic one.

I have a theory that the Valar, sneaky little beings that they are, are the ones who sent the original photos that started all this! If they can send a fake Termination Order in order to get Anne to safety, they can surely send a few photos to get Alex to Wiseman.


KathyGReviewed Chapter: 57 on 3/24/2017
This story is coming along very nicely, and I sure hope that it can be finished! I want to see how it ends, and I know that all of the other readers do, too. Thank you so much for posting it in Fiondil's stead!

BTW, I just wanted to let you know that I've posted a review to one of his other stories: Sent Unto Men: Part II. I posted a question in that review that I'm wondering if you can answer, since Fiondil is not alive to do so.

elrondionReviewed Chapter: 57 on 3/23/2017
thank you, all of you for your continuing hard work. this is a true masterpiece. your blood, sweat and tears are appreciated no matter how far you choose to go. we are with you all the way.

as someone who has been batting 1000 when it comes to guessing, i have another postulation. could the rufus and paul dreams be given to alex because the two are connected to a one 'damien redelfs'? redelfs supposedly came to fairbanks two years ago. the pictures were sent to the agency sometime after christmas a year ago, following which alex enrolled in the academy beginning in the fall term. just wondering.

on an entirely self serving note, the master's writing has inspired me to begin s bit of a continuation entitled wiseman twentieth anniversary. i would be interested in one or more beta readers as well as posting info. over 20 pages have been completed. thank you.

First Page | Previous Page | Next Page | Last Page

Return to Chapter List